Celtic MSS. in relation to the Macpherson fraud: With a review of Professor Freeman's criticism of [P.B. Du Chaillu's] "The Viking Age," by the author of "Celticism a myth"Roger, James Cruikshank
History
Celtic MSS. in relation to the Macpherson fraud: With a review of Professor Freeman's criticism of [P.B. Du Chaillu's] "The Viking Age," by the author of "Celticism a myth"
Roger, James Cruikshank
Celtic literature -- History and criticism; Ossian, active 3rd century
inclines me to pay regard, not to what you shall say, but to what you
shall prove. You may print this if you will.”
We are told that the subject of the Pictish language has been
thoroughly discussed by Dr. W. F. Skene in his _Four Ancient Books
of Wales_, that, in addition to _Pean Fahel_, the sole Pictish word
formerly known he has discovered four other distinct words, besides a
number of syllables entering into proper names; and from all these he
deduces the opinion that Pictish “Is not Welsh, neither is it Gaelic;
but it is a Gaelic dialect partaking largely of Welsh forms” whatever
that may mean. “More especially,” we are told, “he holds that Pictish
as compared with Gaelic, was a _Low_ dialect, that it differed from
the Gaelic in much the same way that Low German differs from High.” It
is perhaps unnecessary to add that I regard this supposed solution of
the Pictish difficulty as so much figment. It is simply the arbitrary
conclusion of a man looking into a mill stone, and giving a deliverance
in regard to which he is in no more commanding position than the
most illiterate specimen of humanity to be found in the slums of the
Northern Metropolis. On the other side of the question it is open to
me to state that the Pictish words which Mr. Skene persuades himself
he has discovered, and which on his own shewing are neither Welsh nor
Gaelic but, belonging to a Low dialect of the latter may after all
be only the obsolete remains of an early Gothic speech. The ruler of
the Picts about the end of the sixth century, it is said, was _Brude_,
the son of _Mailcon_, who died in 586. The most active of all the
Pictish sovereigns, according to the received accounts, was _Hungus_ or
_Ængus_ who began to reign in 730. In so far then as these names may
not be absolute myth, they may be claimed as Scandinavian. With _Brude_
compare the Norse personal names _Brodi_, _Breid-r_, and _Brodd-r_ (the
_r_ final separated by a hyphen being merely the sign of the nominative
case). _Mailcon_ is the united Scandinavian personal names of _Miöl_
and _Kon-r_. With _Hungus_ or _Ængus_ compare the Scoto-Norwegian names
_Magnus Anguson_, and _Angus Magnuson_.
The Norwegians in Man, in the Hebrides, and in the North, and
North-Western Highlands were confessedly the dominant and more numerous
race, and there for upwards of four centuries held uninterrupted sway.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account