Celtic Scotland : $b A history of ancient Alban. Volume 1 (of 3), History and ethnologySkene, W. F. (William Forbes)
History
Celtic Scotland : $b A history of ancient Alban. Volume 1 (of 3), History and ethnology
Skene, W. F. (William Forbes)
Celts -- Scotland; Civilization, Celtic; Scotland -- Antiquities, Celtic; Scotland -- History -- To 1603
It is inconceivable that our best historians should have gone so
entirely against the direct testimony of the older authorities. They
have in this given too much weight to the opinion of Bede, who first
declared the remains of the wall between the Tyne and the Solway to be
those of Severus’s wall, for opinion it is only, and he was naturally
biassed by the remains of the northern rampart being always before his
eyes. Nennius gives the native tradition before his time when he
quotes the passage from Eusebius, and adds, ‘et vocatur Britannico
sermone Guaul a Penguaul quae villa Scotici Cenail, Anglice vero
Peneltun dicitur, usque ad ostium fluminis Cluth et Cairpentaloch, quo
murus ille finitur rustico opere;’ thus clearly placing the wall
between the Forth and Clyde.
Moreover, placing Severus’s wall between the Tyne and Solway involves
the manifest inconsistency, that, after penetrating almost to the end
of the island, and making a peace, in which territory was ceded to
him, he abandoned the whole of his conquests, and withdrew the
frontier of the province to where it had been placed by Hadrian.
Chalmers, who saw this difficulty, supposes that he built the wall
before he commenced his conquests; but this is equally against the
direct statement of the older authorities, that it was built after he
had driven back his enemies and concluded peace. Mr. Bruce has the
pertinent remark that ‘if Severus built the wall (between Tyne and
Solway), we should expect to find frequent intimations of the fact in
the stations and mile castles. The truth, however, is that from
Wallsend to Bowness we do not meet with a single inscription belonging
to the reign of Severus, while we meet with several belonging to that
of Hadrian’ (p. 382).
Footnote 82:
Aurel. Victor. _de Caes._ 39; Eutrop. ix. 21; Orosius, vii. 25.
Footnote 83:
Eumenius, _Paneg. Const._ c. 12. Eutrop. ix. 22.
Footnote 84:
Eumen. _Pan. Const. Caes._ c. 6. Mamert. _Pan. Max. Herc._ c. 11, 12.
Footnote 85:
Comp. Eumenius, ‘prolixo crine rutilantia,’ with Tacitus, ‘rutilae
Caledoniam habitantium comae.’
Footnote 86:
Non dico Caledonum aliorumque Pictorum silvas et paludes.—Eumen. c. 7.
Footnote 87:
Appian. Alex. _Hist. Rom._ Præf. 5. Eumen. _Pan. Const._ cc. 9-19.
Footnote 88:
Sunt in Gallia cum Aquitania et Britanniis decem et octo provinciae
... in Britannia, Maxima Cæsariensis, Flavia, Britannia Prima,
Britannia Secunda.—Sextus Rufus Festus (360), _Brev._ 6.
Footnote 89:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account