Celtic Scotland : $b A history of ancient Alban. Volume 1 (of 3), History and ethnologySkene, W. F. (William Forbes)
History
Celtic Scotland : $b A history of ancient Alban. Volume 1 (of 3), History and ethnology
Skene, W. F. (William Forbes)
Celts -- Scotland; Civilization, Celtic; Scotland -- Antiquities, Celtic; Scotland -- History -- To 1603
The operations of this year have much perplexed historians. The
obvious inference from the passage is that Argyllshire was the region
he visited, and the author has entered thus minutely into the
consideration of what Agricola had to accomplish, and his evident
policy, to show that this was the natural step he would take. It has
generally been supposed that he turned back upon his steps, and that
Galloway was the country ‘opposite to Ireland’ that he visited; but,
as we have seen, its inhabitants could not have been said to be ‘ad id
tempus ignoti,’ and the language of the early geographers rather
characterises Kintyre and the Hebrides as what impressed them most as
overhanging Ireland. Chalmers, in order to avoid the plain inference
from the passage, is driven to suppose that the Tavaus of the third
campaign was the Solway, and that Agricola had advanced no farther,
but this is quite inadmissible. The only alternative, that he crossed
the river Clyde from north to south and entered Ayrshire, is equally
inconsistent with Tacitus’s brief but precise language. Early writers
speak of the Clyde as fordable as far down as Dumbarton, and his
natural course would be to return by the same route as he came.
Tacitus clearly states that he crossed ‘navi in proxima,’ which shows
that it was the estuary, and not the river. The Roman fleet was then
probably in the Firth of Forth, and the expression seems to imply that
he took the first native vessel he could get. There is on an elevated
moor in Cowall, between the Holy Loch and Dunoon, the remains of a
small square fort which has all the appearance of a Roman exploratory
station. It commands an extensive view, in one range, of the entire
Firth to its mouth, the river Clyde for many miles of its straight
course, and Loch Long penetrating in another direction into what was
known to the Romans as the Caledonian Forest, and, if it is a Roman
work, adds strength to the natural reading of the passage, and the
expression, ‘copiis instruxit,’ is singularly applicable.
Footnote 50:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account