Chambers's Edinburgh Journal, No. 451: Volume 18, New Series, August 21, 1852 — John Shaqi
Chambers's Edinburgh Journal, No. 451: Volume 18, New Series, August 21, 1852Various
History
Chambers's Edinburgh Journal, No. 451: Volume 18, New Series, August 21, 1852
Various
Periodicals
The same principle of mental optics is of universal application. We
cannot ignore it without fatal results when studying history, science,
art, human nature, or any conceivable object of inquiry. Thus, in
forming our opinion of the actions of others, there is no more
mischievous absurdity, it has been remarked, than to judge them from
the outside as they look to us, instead of from the inside as they
look to the actors; nothing more irrational than to criticise deeds as
though the doers of them had the same hopes, fears, desires, and
restraints with ourselves. 'We cannot understand another's character
except by abandoning our own identity, and realising to ourselves his
frame of mind, his want of knowledge, his hardships, temptations, and
discouragements.' If we turn to history, we are reminded of Thomas
Moore's lines--
By Tory Hume's seductive page beguiled,
We fancy Charles was just, and Stratford mild;
And Fox himself, with party pencil draws
Monmouth a hero 'for the good old cause!'
Then, rights are wrongs, and victories are defeats,
As French or English pride the tale repeats.
Thus, too, Macaulay remarks, that for many years every Whig historian
was anxious to prove that the old English government was all but
republican--every Tory, to prove it all but despotic. 'With such
feelings, both parties looked into the chronology of the middle ages.
Both readily found what they sought, and obstinately refused to see
anything but what they sought.' Accordingly, to see only one-half of
the evidence, you would conclude that the Plantagenets were as
absolute as the sultans of Turkey; to see only the other half, you
would conclude that they had as little real power as the Doges of
Venice: and both conclusions would be equally remote from the truth.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account