China excels in another art, though her excellence is not admitted
either by the foreign resident or even by the native student. In
certain forms of architecture she is unequalled. Yet when the
Westerner comes to China he glories in bringing with him Western
architecture, indifferent as to whether it is suited to the climatic
conditions or is in itself beautiful. Take, for instance, the English
churches of China. Could any form of architecture be less suited to a
country like China, where the sun is frequently oppressively hot, than
Gothic architecture? The large windows, the pointed arch, and the
weak, open, high-pitched roof may be suitable in a country like ours
which has little sunlight, and where a wet drifting snow will often
force an entrance into the best-designed roof; but in a country like
China, where the sun is the chief difficulty, some construction {139}
should be preferred which renders a heavy and heat-proof roof possible.
If antipathy to the Chinese necessitated a Western type of building,
Italian or even Romanesque architecture might be selected, and a
building with a massive roof supported on solid arches might resist the
rays of the sun. But why not accept the Chinese architecture as
eminently fitted for the climate?
If Christianity is to be assimilated by China and become part of their
national existence, the buildings in which it is proclaimed should be
essentially national. The intention of the Christian should be written
clearly on the face of every landscape where the new and beautiful
Chinese building rises up for the religion which is, as we maintain, as
essentially fitted for the Chinese as it is for the English. We do not
worship in a Roman basilica, but in the buildings that the northern
architects have devised as suitable, both for Christian worship and for
our climate. The new Chinese churches need not be replicas of the
Chinese temples; the object of the building is different, therefore the
building should differ, but there are many other forms in which it is
possible for the architect to express in Chinese architecture the
eternal truths of Christianity.
Again, why are all the schools and colleges erected on Western
patterns. The Chinese are used to and prefer their own architecture,
and from a sanitary point of view I hardly think it is inferior. The
average Westerner in China has but one idea, and {140} that is that the
Chinese must become like a Western nation or must remain untouched by
Western civilisation. He absolutely refuses the suggestion that the
architecture of China can be altered to suit modern conditions.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account