Charles Darwin and the Theory of Natural SelectionPoulton, Edward Bagnall, Sir
Science
Charles Darwin and the Theory of Natural Selection
Poulton, Edward Bagnall, Sir
Darwin, Charles, 1809-1882; Natural selection
About a month before the “Origin” was published, Darwin wrote to
Professor Huxley asking for the names of foreigners to whom to send his
book. This communication is of great interest as being the earliest
letter, accessible to the public, which he wrote to Huxley. In it he
says: “I shall be _intensely_ curious to hear what effect the book
produces on you”; but he evidently thought that Huxley would disagree
with much in it, and must have been surprised as well as gratified at
the way in which it was received. In his chapter “On the Reception of
the ‘Origin of Species’” (“Life and Letters,” Vol. II.), Huxley writes:
“My reflection, when I first made myself master of the central idea of
the ‘Origin,’ was, ‘How extremely stupid not to have thought of that.’”
Huxley replied on November 23rd, 1859--the day before the publication
of the “Origin”--saying that he had finished the book on the previous
day. His letter was a complete acceptance of evolution as apart from
any theory which may account for it; and a thorough agreement with
natural selection as a “true cause for the production of species.”
At no time in his life did he state how far he considered natural
selection to be a sufficient cause. He was only “prepared to go to the
stake, if requisite, in support of” the chapters which marshal the
evidence for evolution (ix., and most parts of x., xi., and xii.).
With regard to the earlier chapters, which propound the theory of
natural selection, his exact words are:--
“As to the first four chapters, I agree thoroughly and fully
with all the principles laid down in them. I think you have
demonstrated a true cause for the production of species, and have
thrown the _onus probandi_, that species did not arise in the way
you suppose, on your adversaries.”
Darwin replied with much warmth, and expressed himself as “Now
contented and able to sing my _Nunc Dimittis_.”
In the _Times_ of December 26th, 1859, appeared a masterly article upon
the “Origin,” and, after a time, it became known that Huxley was its
author. Volume II. of the “Life and Letters” explains the circumstances
under which the review was written. The article is reprinted as the
first essay (“The Darwinian Hypothesis,” I.) in “Darwiniana” (Vol.
II. of the “Collected Essays of Professor Huxley,” London, 1893). The
following quotation (pp. 19, 20) shows the attitude he took up with
regard to natural selection:--
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account