Charles Dickens: A critical studyChesterton, G. K. (Gilbert Keith)
General
Charles Dickens: A critical study
Chesterton, G. K. (Gilbert Keith)
Dickens, Charles, 1812-1870
The key of the great characters of Dickens is that they are all great
fools. There is the same difference between a great fool and a small
fool as there is between a great poet and a small poet. The great fool
is a being who is above wisdom rather than below it. That element of
greatness of which I spoke at the beginning of this book is nowhere
more clearly indicated than in such characters. A man can be entirely
great while he is entirely foolish. We see this in the epic heroes,
such as Achilles. Nay, a man can be entirely great because he is
entirely foolish. We see this in all the great comic characters of
all the great comic writers of whom Dickens was the last. Bottom the
Weaver is great because he is foolish; Mr. Toots is great because he is
foolish. The thing I mean can be observed, for instance, in innumerable
actual characters. Which of us has not known, for instance, a great
rustic?--a character so incurably characteristic that he seemed to
break through all canons about cleverness or stupidity; we do not
know whether he is an enormous idiot or an enormous philosopher; we
know only that he is enormous, like a hill. These great, grotesque
characters are almost entirely to be found where Dickens found
them--among the poorer classes. The gentry only attain this greatness
by going slightly mad. But who has not known an unfathomably personal
old nurse? Who has not known an abysmal butler? The truth is that our
public life consists almost exclusively of small men. Our public men
are small because they have to prove that they are in the common-place
interpretation clever, because they have to pass examinations, to
learn codes of manners, to imitate a fixed type. It is in private life
that we find the great characters. They are too great to get into the
public world. It is easier for a camel to pass through the eye of a
needle than for a great man to enter into the kingdoms of the earth.
The truly great and gorgeous personality, he who talks as no one else
could talk and feels with an elementary fire, you will never find
this man on any cabinet bench, in any literary circle, at any society
dinner. Least of all will you find him in artistic society; he is
utterly unknown in Bohemia. He is more than clever, he is amusing.
He is more than successful, he is alive. You will find him stranded
here and there in all sorts of unknown positions, almost always in
unsuccessful positions. You will find him adrift as an impecunious
commercial traveller like Micawber. You will find him but one of
a batch of silly clerks, like Swiveller. You will find him as an
unsuccessful actor, like Crummles. You will find him as an unsuccessful
doctor, like Sawyer. But you will always find this rich and reeking
personality where Dickens found it--among the poor. For the glory of
this world is a very small and priggish affair, and these men are too
large to get in line with it. They are too strong to conquer.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account