The "Elements of Geology" was finally published a few weeks before the
Newcastle meeting, and the work of recasting the "Principles" went on at
intervals in preparation for the sixth edition, which appeared in 1840.
If, in accordance with the maxim, a nation is happy which has no
history, Lyell ought to have passed almost a year in a state of
felicity, for nothing is recorded between September 6th, 1838, when he
writes to Charles Darwin from Kinnordy, and August 1st, 1839, when he
writes to Dr. Fitton from the same place. Both these letters are
interesting. The former discusses the relation of Darwin's theory of the
formation of coral islands with E. de Beaumont's idea of the
contemporaneity of parallel mountain chains, which has been already
mentioned. One passage also throws light upon the difficulties with
which the British Association in its earlier days had to contend. Some
of the most influential newspapers had set themselves to write it
down--needless to say, without success. Good sense sometimes is too
strong even for newspapers. But Lyell thus urges Darwin[88]:--
"Do not let Broderip, or the _Times_ or the _Age_ or _John
Bull_, nor any papers, whether of saints or sinners, induce
you to join in running down the British Association. I do
not mean to insinuate that you ever did so, but I have
myself often seen its faults in a strong light, and am aware
of what may be urged against philosophers turning public
orators, etc. But I am convinced--although it is not the way
I love to spend my own time--that in this country no
importance is attached to any body of men who do not make
occasional demonstrations of their strength in public
meetings. It is a country where, as Tom Moore justly
complained, a most exaggerated importance is attached to the
faculty of thinking on your legs, and where, as Dan
O'Connell very well knows, nothing is to be got in the way
of homage or influence, or even a fair share of power,
without agitation."
Far-reaching words, the truth of which has been demonstrated again and
again during the years which have elapsed since they were written. Lyell
lays his finger on the weakest spot in the nature of the true-born
Briton: he is deaf to quiet reasoning, and frightened by loud shoutings.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account