By the Mexican War Bill (approved May 13, 1846) the President was
authorized "to call for and accept the services of any number
of volunteers, not exceeding fifty thousand," and provision was
made for their organization. The Governor of Massachusetts, by
proclamation, called for a Regiment in this Commonwealth, which
was organized under the Act of Congress. Before it had left the
Commonwealth, applications for discharge were made to the Supreme
Court of Massachusetts in behalf of several persons repenting
their too hasty enlistment. At the hearing, the proceedings by
which the Regiment had been organized were called in question.
Their validity was denied on the ground that the Act of Congress,
in some of its essential provisions concerning volunteers, was
unconstitutional,--that the enlistments were not in conformity
with the Act,--and also that the militia laws of Massachusetts had
been fraudulently used in forming the regiment. These points, and
the further question, whether a minor is bound by his contract of
enlistment under the Act, were argued by Mr. Sumner, who appeared
as counsel for one of the petitioners. The Court sustained the
validity of the proceedings, but discharged the minors.--See _In
Re_ Kimball, Murray, and Stone, 9 Law Reporter, 500, where the case
is reported.
MAY IT PLEASE YOUR HONORS,
This cause has a strong claim upon the careful consideration of the
Court. It comes with a _trinoda necessitas_, a triple cord, to bind its
judgment. It is important as respects the parties, the public, and the
principles involved.
To the _parties_, it is one of the highest questions known to the
law, being a question of _human freedom_. It is proposed to hold the
petitioner in the servitude of the army for an indefinite space of
time, namely, "for the duration of the war with Mexico." During all
this period, he will be subject to martial law, and to the Articles of
War, with the terrible penalties of desertion. He will be under the
command of officers, at whose word he must move from place to place
beyond the confines of the country, and perform unwelcome duties,
involving his own life and the lives of others.
To the _public_, it is important, as it is surely of especial
consequence, in whose hands is placed the power of life and death. The
soldier is vested with extraordinary attributes. He is at times more
than marshal or sheriff. He is also surrounded by the law with certain
immunities, one of which is exemption from imprisonment for debt.
It is important from the _principles_ involved. These are the
distinctions between the different kinds of military force under the
Constitution of the United States, the constitutionality of the Act
of Congress of May, 1846, and the legality of the enlistments under
it. The determination of these questions will establish or annul the
immense and complex Volunteer System now set in motion.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account