Charles Sumner: his complete works, volume 02 (of 20)Sumner, Charles
History
Charles Sumner: his complete works, volume 02 (of 20)
Sumner, Charles
Slavery -- United States; Speeches, addresses, etc., American
The vote of which I have spoken will cause, I do not fear to
say, a painful surprise to almost all those in Europe who are
devoted to the Prison question. They will interpret it as a solemn
determination taken by the Society to make itself the champion of
the Auburn System, and the systematic adversary of the Separate
System. Instead of a judge, it will seem to become a party.
I need not inform you, that, at the present day, in Europe,
discussion and experience have, on the contrary, led almost all
persons of intelligence to adopt the Separate System, and to
reject the Auburn System. Most of the governments of the Old
World have declared themselves more or less in this way, not
hastily, but after serious inquiry and long debates. I will speak
only of the two great free nations of Europe,--those which I know
the best, and which are the most worthy of being regarded as an
authority, wherever questions are decided only after discussion
before the country, and obedience is rendered to public opinion
alone,--France and England. Among these two nations, I can assure
you, the Auburn System is almost universally rejected. The greater
part of those who had previously inclined towards this system
have completely abandoned it, when they came to discuss it, or
to see it in operation, and have adopted, wholly or in part, the
system of Separate Imprisonment. The two governments have followed
the same tendencies. You know that the French government brought
forward, a few years since, a law, of which separate imprisonment
formed the basis. This law after a discussion of five weeks,
the longest and most thorough which has ever taken place in our
parliament on any question, was voted by an _immense majority_.
If this same law has not yet been discussed in the Chamber of
Peers, the reason is to be found in circumstances entirely foreign
to the Penitentiary Question. The Chamber of Peers will take it
into consideration at the opening of the approaching session; and
among the most considerable men in this Chamber, the greater part
have already pronounced openly in favor of its principle. As to
the press, almost all the journals sustain the system of Separate
Imprisonment. The journal which had most skilfully and earnestly
combated the system has recently declared itself convinced of
its excellence. This change has been produced, in part, by the
experience had for many years in a large number of our prisons.
Indeed, it may be doubted, whether, when the law shall be reported
to the Chamber of Peers, there will be found a single person to
combat its _principle_.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account