Charles Sumner: his complete works, volume 02 (of 20)Sumner, Charles
History
Charles Sumner: his complete works, volume 02 (of 20)
Sumner, Charles
Slavery -- United States; Speeches, addresses, etc., American
"The Tatler," in considering the Roman triumph, notices that
"it was not allowed in a civil war, lest one part should be in
tears, while the other was making acclamations." (No. LXIII.) And
Hudibras, in a most suggestive passage, uses language applicable to
all civil war:--
"What towns, what garrisons, might you
With hazard of this blood subdue,
Which now ye're bent to throw away
_In vain untriumphable fray_!"
Part I. Canto II. 499-502.
_International War criminal, and as little worthy of honor as Civil
War._--Erasmus dealt a blow at the distinction, still preserved
among Christians, between _civil_ war and _foreign_ war. "_Plato
civile bellum esse putat, quod Græci gerunt adversus Græcos. At
Christianus Christiano propius junctus est quam civis civi, quam
frater fratri._" (Erasmi Epist., Lib. XXII. Ep. 16.) The same idea
is found in the Byzantine Gregoras: "Indecorum esse Christianis
tanta cum acerbitate inter se armis certare, cum rationes sint
conveniendi ad pacem et communes vires in impios vertendi."
(Gregoras, Lib. X., De Alexandro Bulgaro, quoted by Grotius, De
Jure Belli ac Pacis, Lib. II. cap. 23, §8, No. 3, note.) Even here
it is rather the Brotherhood of Christians than the Brotherhood
of Man that is recognized. Assuming the latter, international war
becomes criminal, and as little worthy of honor as civil war. It
is a war among brothers.
Who can think of that contest between the two brothers Eteocles and
Polynices without abhorrence? Who would think of awarding glory to
Abel, if, in self-defence, he had succeeded in slaying his hostile
brother, Cain? There is a play of Beaumont and Fletcher where two
brothers are represented as drawing swords upon each other. When
finally separated, they are addressed in words applicable to the
contests of nations:--
"Clashing of swords
So near my house! Brother opposed to brother!
.. .. .. . Hold! hold!
Charles! Eustace!
.. .. . But these unnatural jars,
Arising between brothers, _should you prosper,
Would shame your victory_"
_The Elder Brother_, Act V. Sc. 1.
The unreasonableness of any True Glory in such a contest is felt
by all at the present day, though there have been monsters or
barbarians who _gloried_ even in a kinsman's blood. Massinger, in
his play of "The Unnatural Combat," has portrayed such a character.
A father and son fight with each other. The father is victorious.
His exultation in the death of his son is not unlike that which
often attends the victories of Christian nations:--
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account