Charles Sumner: his complete works, volume 14 (of 20)Sumner, Charles
History
Charles Sumner: his complete works, volume 14 (of 20)
Sumner, Charles
Slavery -- United States; Speeches, addresses, etc., American
But now we are driven to a pass: justice threatens to fail in the
Supreme Court, unless we provide relief. Is the bill of the Senator
from New York adequate? Speaking frankly, I fear that it is not; and I
fear that the proposition of my friend from Wisconsin [Mr. HOWE], if
adopted, will still further limit the relief which my friend from New
York proposes. I am disposed to believe that the only real relief will
be found in setting apart the judges of our highest court exclusively
for the consideration of appeals. They would then sit as many months
in the year as they could reasonably give to judicial labor. They
might, perhaps, hear every case that could reach the tribunal, while
they had a vacation to themselves in which to review the science of
their profession and add undoubtedly to their attainments. I remember
that one of the ablest lawyers in England, in testimony some years
ago before a Committee of the House of Commons on the value of what
is known as the vacation,--I refer to Sir James Scarlett, afterward
Lord Abinger, Lord Chief Baron,--testified that for one, as an old
lawyer, he regarded the vacation as important, because it gave him
an opportunity to review his studies and to read books that he could
not read in the urgency of practice. I have heard our own judges make
similar remarks.
Now the question is, whether the present bill meets the case. Does it
supply the needed relief? I fear it does not; and I really should be
much better satisfied, if my friend from New York had dealt more boldly
with the whole question by providing a court of appeal, composed of the
eminent judges of the land, devoted exclusively to appeals, and leaving
to other judges the hearing of cases at _Nisi Prius_.
THE LATE SOLOMON FOOT, SENATOR FROM VERMONT.
SPEECH IN THE SENATE, ON HIS DEATH, APRIL 12, 1866.
MR. PRESIDENT,--There is a truce in this Chamber. The antagonism of
debate is hushed. The sounds of conflict have died away. The white
flag is flying. From opposite camps we meet to bury the dead. It is a
Senator we bury, not a soldier.
This is the second time during the present session that we have been
called to mourn a distinguished Senator from Vermont. It was much
to bear the loss once. Its renewal now, after so brief a period, is
a calamity without precedent in the history of the Senate. No State
before has ever lost two Senators so near together.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account