Charles Sumner: his complete works, volume 16 (of 20)Sumner, Charles
History
Charles Sumner: his complete works, volume 16 (of 20)
Sumner, Charles
Slavery -- United States; Speeches, addresses, etc., American
Would you know the incalculable mischief of State pretensions? The
American continent furnishes three different examples, each worthy
of extended contemplation. There are, first, our Indians, aborigines
of the soil, split into tribes, possessing a barbarous independence,
but through this perverse influence kept in constant strife, with
small chance of improvement. Each chief is a representative of State
pretensions. Turning the back upon union, they turn the back upon
civilization itself. There is, next, our neighbor republic, Mexico,
where Nature is bountiful in vain, and climate lends an unavailing
charm, while twenty-three States, unwilling to recognize the national
power, set up their disorganizing pretensions, and chaos becomes
chronic. The story is full of darkness and tragedy. The other instance
is our own, where sacrifices of all kinds, public and private, rise
up in blood before us. Civil war, wasted treasure, debt, wounds, and
death are the witnesses. With wailing voice all these cry out against
the deadly enemy lurking in State pretensions. But this wail is heard
from the beginning of history, saddening its pages from generation to
generation.
In ancient times the City-State was the highest type, as in Greece,
where every city was a State, proud of its miniature sovereignty. The
natural consequences ensued. Alliances, leagues, and confederations
were ineffectual against State pretensions. The parts failed to
recognize the whole and its natural supremacy. Amidst all the triumphs
of genius and the splendors of art, there was no national life, and
Greece died. From her venerable sepulchre, with ever-burning funeral
lamps, where was buried so much of mortal beauty, there is a constant
voice of warning, which sounds across continent and ocean, echoing
“Beware!”
Rome also was a City-State. If it assumed at any time the national
form, it was only because the conquering republic took to itself all
other communities and melted them in its fiery crucible. But this
dominion was of force, ending in universal empire, where the consent
of the governed was of little account. How incalculably different from
a well-ordered Nation, where all is natural, and the people are knit
together in self-imposed bonds!
Then came the colossal power of Charlemagne, under whom peoples and
provinces were accumulated into one incongruous mass. Here again was
universal empire, but there was no Nation.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account