Childhood in literature and art, with some observations on literature for children : $b A studyScudder, Horace Elisha
History
Childhood in literature and art, with some observations on literature for children : $b A study
Scudder, Horace Elisha
Children in art; Children in literature
I have been led into a long digression through the natural correlation
which exists between childhood in literature and a literature for
children. Let me get back to my main topic by a similar path. The one
author in America whose works yield the most fruitful examples in
illustration of our subject is Hawthorne, and at the same time he is
the most masterly of all our authors who have aimed at writing for an
audience of children. Whatever may become of the great mass of books for
young people published in America during the past fifty years,—and most
of it is already crumbling in memory,—it requires no heroism to predict
an immortality of fame for the little books which Hawthorne wrote with
so much good nature and evident pleasure, Grandfather’s Chair and the
Wonder Book, with its companion, Tanglewood Tales. Mr. Parkman has given
a new reading in the minds of many people to the troubles in Acadia, but
he has not disturbed the vitality of Evangeline; one may add footnote
after footnote to modify or correct the statements in The Courtship of
Miles Standish, but the poem will continue to be accepted as a picture
of Pilgrim times. So the researches of antiquarians, with more material
at their command than Hawthorne enjoyed, may lead them to different
conclusions from those which he reached in his sketches of early New
England history, but they cannot destroy that charm in the rendering
which makes the book a classic.
More notable still is Hawthorne’s version of Greek myths. Probably he
had no further authority for the stories than Lemprière. He only added
the touch of his own genius. Only! and the old rods blossomed with
a new variety of fruit and flower. It is easily said that Hawthorne
Yankeeized the stories, that he used the Greek stones for constructing a
Gothic building, but this is academic criticism. He really succeeded in
naturalizing the Greek myths in American soil, and all the labors of all
the Coxes will not succeed in supplanting them. Moreover, I venture to
think that Hawthorne’s fame is more firmly fixed by means of the Wonder
Book. The presence of an audience of children had a singular power over
him. I do not care for the embroidery of actual child life which he has
devised for these tales; it is scarcely more than a fashion, and already
strikes one as quaint and out of date. But I cannot read the tales
themselves without being aware that Hawthorne was breathing one air when
he was writing them and another when he was at work on his romances. He
illustrates in a delicate and subtle manner the line of Juvenal which
bids the old remember the respect due to the young. Juvenal uses it to
shame men into decorum; but just as any sensitive person will restrain
himself in expression before children, so Hawthorne appears to have
restrained his thought in their silent presence,—to have done this, and
also to have admitted into it the sunshine which their presence brought.
With what bright and joyous playfulness he repeats the old stories,
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account