Church History, Volume 1 (of 3)Kurtz, J. H. (Johann Heinrich)
Religion
Church History, Volume 1 (of 3)
Kurtz, J. H. (Johann Heinrich)
Church history
in 4 parts, Freib., 1876 ff.; 2nd ed., 1879, with a
supplement: Sources, Literat., and Foundations). In this work
he draws upon the rich stores of his acknowledged scholarship,
which, however, often strangely forsakes him in treating of the
history of Protestant theology. It is a skilful and instructive
exposition, and may very fitly be represented as “a history of
the church, yea, of the whole world, viewed through correctly set
Romish spectacles.” Far beneath him in scientific importance, but
in obstinate ultramontanism far above him, stands the _Lehrbuch_
of =H. Bruck [Brück]= (2nd ed., Mainz, 1877). A far more solid
production is presented in the _Dissertatt. selectæ in hist.
ecclst._ of Prof. =B. Jungmann= of Louvain, which treat in
chronological succession of parties and controversies prominent
in church history, especially of the historical development of
doctrine, in a thorough manner and with reference to original
documents, not without a prepossession in favour of Vaticanism
(vols. i.-iii., Ratisb., 1880-1883, reaching down to the end
of the 9th cent.). The _Kirchenlexikon_ of Wetzer and Wette
(12 vols., Freib., 1847 ff.) gained a prominent place on account
of the articles on church history contributed by the most eminent
Catholic scholars, conceived for the most part in the scientific
spirit of Möhler. The very copious and of its kind admirably
executed 2nd ed. by Kaulen (Freib., 1880 ff.), under the
auspices of Card. Hergenröther, is conceived in a far more
decidedly Papistic-Vatican spirit, which often does not
shrink from maintaining and vindicating even the most glaring
productions of mediæval superstition, illusion and credulity,
as grounded in indubitable historical facts. Much more
important is the historical research in the _Hist. Jahrbuch
der Görres-Gesellschaft_, edited from 1880 by G. Hüffer, and
from 1883 by B. Gramich, which presents itself as “a means of
reconciliation for those historians with whom Christ is the
middle point of history and the Catholic Church the God-ordained
institution for the education of the human race.”--In the French
Church the following are the most important productions: the
_Hist. de l’égl._ of =Berault-Bercastel= (24 vols., Par., 1778
ff.), which have had many French continuators and also a German
translator (24 vols., Vienna, 1784 ff.); the _Hist. ecclst.
depuis la création_, etc., of =Baron Henrion=, ed. by Migne
(25 vols., Par., 1852 ff.); and the very diffuse compilation,
wholly devoted to the glorification of the Papacy and its
institutions, _Hist. universelle de l’égl. Cath._ of the Louvain
French Abbé Rohrbacher (29 vols., Par., 1842 ff.; of which an
English transl. is in course of publication). Finally, the
scientifically careful exposition of the Old Catholic =J. Rieks=,
_Gesch. d. chr. K. u. d. Papstthums_, Lahr., 1882, though in some
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account