Civilization in the United States: An inquiry by thirty Americans
General
Civilization in the United States: An inquiry by thirty Americans
United States -- Civilization
A trivial example will serve to illustrate the possible advantages
of a cultural foundation for very specialized research. Music is
notoriously one of the salient features of German culture, not merely
because Germany has produced great composers but because of the wide
appreciation and quite general study of music. Artistically the
knowledge of the piano or violin acquired by the average child in
the typical German home may count for naught, yet in at least two
branches of inquiry it may assume importance. The psychological aspect
of acoustics is likely to attract and to be fruitfully cultivated by
those conversant with musical technique, and they alone will be capable
of grappling with the comparative problems presented by the study
of primitive music--problems that would never occur to the average
Anglo-Saxon field ethnologist, yet to which the German would apply his
knowledge as spontaneously as he applies the multiplication table to a
practical matter of everyday purchase.
As a matter of fact, all the phenomena of the universe are interrelated
and, accordingly, the most important advances may be expected from a
revelation of the less patent connections. For this purpose a diversity
of interests with corresponding variety of information may be not only
a favourable condition but a prerequisite. Helmholtz may have made an
indifferent physician; but because he combined a medical practitioner’s
knowledge with that of a physicist he was enabled to devise the
ophthalmoscope. So it may be that not one out of ten thousand men
who might apply themselves to higher mathematics would ever be able
to advance mathematical theory, but it is certainly true that the
manipulatory skill acquired would stand them in good stead not only in
the exact sciences but in biology, psychology, and anthropometry, in
all of which the theory of probability can be effectively applied to
the phenomenon of variability.
I do not mean to assert that the average European student is an
Admirable Crichton utilizing with multidexterity the most diverse
methods of research and groups of fact. But I am convinced that
many European workers produce more valuable work than equally able
Americans for the sole reason that the European’s social heritage
provides him with agencies ready-made for detecting correlations that
must inevitably elude a vision narrower because deprived of the same
artificial aid. The remedy lies in enriching the cultural atmosphere
and in insisting on a broad educational training over and above that
devoted to the specialist’s craftsmanship.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account