Civilization in the United States: An inquiry by thirty Americans
General
Civilization in the United States: An inquiry by thirty Americans
United States -- Civilization
The constitution, of course, stops with Congress, but its influence
is naturally powerful within the States, and one finds proofs of the
fact on all sides. It is taking an herculean effort everywhere to break
down even the worst effects of this influence; the prevailing tendency
is still to discover a mysterious virtue in the office-holder who was
born and raised in the State, or county, or city, or ward. The judge
must come from the bar of the court he is to adorn; the mayor must be
part and parcel of the local machine; even technical officers, such
as engineers and health commissioners, lie under the constitutional
blight. The thing began as a belief in local self-government, the
oldest of all the sure cures for despotism. But it has gradually taken
on the character of government by local politicians, which is to say,
by persons quite unable to comprehend the most elemental problems of
State and nation, and unfitted by nature to deal with them honestly
and patriotically, even if they could comprehend them. Just as
prohibition was forced upon the civilized minorities collected in the
great cities against their most vigorous and persistent opposition,
so the same minorities, when it comes to intra-state affairs, are
constantly at the mercy of predatory bands of rural politicians. If
there is any large American city whose peculiar problems are dealt
with competently and justly by its State legislature, then I must
confess that twenty years in journalism have left me ignorant of it. An
unending struggle for fairer dealing goes on in every State that has
large cities, and every concession to their welfare is won only at the
cost of gigantic effort. The State legislature is never intelligent;
it represents only the average mind of the county bosses, whose sole
concern is with jobs. The machines that they represent are wholly
political, but they have no political principles in any rational sense.
Their one purpose and function is to maintain their adherents in the
public offices, or to obtain for them in some other way a share of
the State funds. They are quite willing to embrace any new doctrine,
however fantastic, or to abandon any old one, however long supported,
if only the business will promote their trade and so secure their power.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account