Civilization in the United States: An inquiry by thirty Americans
General
Civilization in the United States: An inquiry by thirty Americans
United States -- Civilization
There is no need in this post-Freudian day of dwelling upon the effects
of suppression of sex instinct or impulse. Suppression leads, we are
told, either to sublimation, in which case it is diversion, rather
than suppression, or it leads to perversion or disease. Unfortunately
sex-pathology in the United States has been given little or no study,
statistically. We have no statistical data of health or disease in
relation to the expression or suppression of sex instinct, and no data
on the extent or the effects of homosexuality or of the direction
of the sex impulses towards self. Opinion therefore becomes merely
a matter of personal observation and conclusion, observation of
individuals or small groups. My own conclusion or guess in regard
to perversion in this country is that part of the commonly observed
spirit of isolation or antagonism between the sexes, and part of
the spirit of competition between individuals, are associated with
homosexual or masturbatory tendencies which get expressed in varying
degrees according to varying circumstances. More particularly the
lack of warmth in personal intercourse which makes alike for American
bad manners and, in the more intellectual circles, for cheerlessness
and aridity is due, I think, to failure of one kind or another in sex
relations. I mean cultural failure, not merely individual failure.
May not some such theory of sex failure account also for that herd
sense which is so familiar a part of Americanism, and which is not
incompatible with the type of self-seeking or pseudo-individualism
of which American individualism appears to be an expression? It is a
tenable hypothesis that sexually isolated individuals become dependent
upon the group for stimulus, whether of emotion or will, whereas
persons in normal sex relations, although they may contribute to the
group or co-operate with it, remain comparatively independent of it,
finding stimulus in sex and its sublimations.
If this theory is valid, we may expect to find a comparatively large
number of sex failures in those circles which are characterized by
what Everett Dean Martin has recently called crowd behaviour, reform
circles intolerant of other mindedness and obsessed by belief in the
paramountcy of their own dogma.
“_Leur printemps sans jeunesse exige des folies,
Leur sang brûlant leur dicte des propos amers,
L’émeute est un remède à la mélancolie,
Et nous aurions la paix si leurs yeux étaient clairs,
Ou leur femme jolie._”
Were a set of tests for sex failure or sex fulfilment applied to the
more outstanding propagandists of this country, likewise, of course,
for comparative purposes, to an adequate number of non-propagandists,
the results might be of considerable significance. I recommend the
undertaking to the National Research Council in co-operation with some
organization for social hygiene.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account