Civilization in the United States: An inquiry by thirty Americans
General
Civilization in the United States: An inquiry by thirty Americans
United States -- Civilization
It may seem strange that a volume on civilization in the United States
does not include a specific article on religion, and the omission is
worth a paragraph of explanation. Outside the bigger cities, certainly
no one can understand the social structure of contemporary American
life without careful study of the organization and power of the church.
Speaking generally, we are a church-going people, and at least on the
surface the multiplicity of sects and creeds, the sheer immensity of
the physical apparatus by which the religious impulse is articulated,
would seem to prove that our interest in and emotional craving for
religious experience are enormous. But the omission has not been due
to any superciliousness on our part towards the subject itself; on the
contrary, I suppose I have put more thought and energy into this essay,
which has not been written, than into any other problem connected with
the book. The bald truth is, it has been next to impossible to get any
one to write on the subject; most of the people I approached shied
off--it was really difficult to get them to talk about it at all.
Almost unanimously, when I did manage to procure an opinion from them,
they said that real religious feeling in America had disappeared, that
the church had become a purely social and political institution, that
the country is in the grip of what Anatole France has aptly called
Protestant clericalism, and that, finally, they weren’t interested
in the topic. The accuracy of these observations (except the last) I
cannot, of course, vouch for, but it is rather striking that they were
identical. In any event, the topic as a topic has had to be omitted;
but it is not neglected, for in several essays directly--in particular,
“Philosophy” and “Nerves”--and in many by implication the subject is
discussed. At one time Mr. James Harvey Robinson consented to write
the article--and it would have been an illuminating piece of work--but
unfortunately ill health and the pressure of official duties made the
task impossible for him within the most generous time limit that might
be arranged.
I have spoken already of the unity which underlies the volume. When
I remember all these essays, and try to summon together the chief
themes that run through them, either by explicit statement or as a
kind of underlying rhythm to all, in order to justify the strong
impression of unity, I find three major contentions that may be said to
be basic--contentions all the more significant inasmuch as they were
unpremeditated and were arrived at, as it were, by accident rather than
design. They are:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account