Clara Barton National Historic Site, MarylandUnited States. National Park Service
History
Clara Barton National Historic Site, Maryland
United States. National Park Service
Barton, Clara, 1821-1912; Clara Barton National Historic Site (Md.)
Clara Barton was familiar with these organizations, and, especially in
the latter part of the war, often worked alongside them. But though
she wrote publicly that their labor was always in “perfect accord,
mutual respect and friendliness,” she chose to work alone rather than
align herself too closely with the commissions. Barton’s natural
leadership and difficulty in working with others prompted her to
remain independent, where she would not be “compromised by them in the
least.” Furthermore, she secretly scorned the commissions’ work, which
she thought inexperienced and impractical: “an old fudge” she called
the Sanitary Commission in her journal.
Barton also chose not to work with Dorothea Dix’s “Department of
Female Nurses.” A compulsive humanitarian worker, Dix had volunteered
her services to the War Department at the opening of hostilities. Her
offer was accepted and Dix began the impossible task of collecting
supplies, selecting nurses, and supervising hospitals for the Union
army. Dix was a perfectionist and her dogmatic and strident opinions
won her few friends. But her sharp altercations with physicians and
officers resulted more from frustration because she could not relieve
the massive misery, than from an over-bearing personality. Feeling
that she had failed to achieve her mission, Dix wrote at war’s end:
“This is not the work I would have my life judged by.”
The use of female nurses was an innovation during the Civil War and
Dix was anxious for the women under her to be taken seriously. Fearful
that nursing would become a sport among adventurous young women, she
laid down stringent and inflexible rules for nurses. These rules would
have greatly hampered Clara Barton’s independent spirit and this is
one reason she chose not to join Dix’s force.
In addition to the official organizations there were numerous “unsung
heroes” during the Civil War. Most notable were the religious orders
such as the Sisters of Charity who calmly defied the army’s
restrictions and worked both at the front and in hospitals. Despite
the fact that such diverse groups inevitably caused conflicts and
jealousies, the Civil War provided a field large enough for all of the
humanitarian organizations which labored in it.
[Illustration: _Mary Ann Bickerdyke_]
[Illustration: _Walt Whitman_]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account