No amount of description, arrangement, and classification, however
perfect or accurate, of the facts which come under the eye of the
geologist can ever constitute a science of geology any more than a
description and classification of the effects of heat could constitute
a science of heat. This will, no doubt, be admitted by every one who
reflects upon the subject, and it will be maintained that geology,
like every other science, must possess principles applicable to the
facts. But here confusion and misconception will arise unless there be
distinct and definite ideas as to what ought to constitute a geological
principle. It is not every statement or rule that may apply to a great
many facts, which will constitute a geological principle. A geological
principle must bear the same characteristics as the principles of those
sciences to which we have referred. What, then, is the nature of the
principles of light, heat, electricity, &c.? The principles of heat
are the laws of heat. The principles of electricity are the laws of
electricity. And these laws are nothing more nor less than the ways
according to which these agents produce their effects. The principles
of geology are therefore the laws of geology. But the laws of geology
must be simply the laws of the geological agents, or, in other words,
the methods by which they produce their effects. Any other so-called
principle can be nothing more than an empirical rule, adopted for
convenience. Possessing no rationality in itself, it cannot be justly
regarded as a principle. In order to rationality the principle must be
either resolvable into, or logically deducible from, the laws of the
agents. Unless it possess this quality we cannot give the explanation
_à priori_.
The reason of all this is perfectly obvious. The things to be explained
are effects; and the relationship between cause and effect affords the
subjective connection between the principle and the explanation. The
explanation follows from the principle simply as the effect results
from the laws of the agent or cause.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account