The only other theory on the subject worthy of notice is that
of Sir Charles Lyell. Those extraordinary changes of climate are,
according to his theory, attributed to differences in the distribution
of land and water. Sir Charles concludes that, were the land all
collected round the poles, while the equatorial zones were occupied by
the ocean, the general temperature would be lowered to an extent that
would account for the glacial epoch. And, on the other hand, were the
land all collected along the equator, while the polar regions were
covered with sea, this would raise the temperature of the globe to an
enormous extent. It will be shown in subsequent chapters that this
theory does not duly take into account the prodigious influence exerted
on climate by means of the heat conveyed from equatorial to temperate
and polar regions by means of ocean-currents. In Chapters II. and III.
I have endeavoured to prove (1), that were it not for the heat conveyed
from equatorial to temperate and polar regions by this means, the
thermal condition of the globe would be totally different from what it
is at present; and (2), that the effect of placing all the land along
the equator would be diametrically the opposite of that which Sir
Charles supposes.
But supposing that difference in the distribution of land and water
would produce the effects attributed to it, nevertheless it would not
account for those extraordinary changes of climate which have occurred
during geological epochs. Take, for example, the glacial epoch.
Geologists almost all agree that little or no change has taken place
in the relative distribution of sea and land since that _epoch_. All
our main continents and islands not only existed then as they do now,
but every year is adding to the amount of evidence which goes to show
that so recent, geologically considered, is the glacial epoch that the
very contour of the surface was pretty much the same then as it is at
the present day. But this is not all; for even should we assume (1),
that a difference in the distribution of sea and land would produce the
effects referred to, and (2), that we had good geological evidence to
show that at a very recent period a form of distribution existed which
would produce the necessary glacial conditions, still the glacial
epoch would not be explained, for the phenomena of warm inter-glacial
periods would completely upset the theory.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account