Comparative ReligionCarpenter, J. Estlin (Joseph Estlin)
Religion
Comparative Religion
Carpenter, J. Estlin (Joseph Estlin)
Religions
But behind the external evolution of a given religion, its modes of
worship, its ministers, its doctrines, lie more complicated questions.
What causes shaped these acts and moulded these beliefs? What elements
of race are to be discerned in them? How can we account for the
diversities between the religions of peoples belonging to a common
stock, like those of India and those of ancient Italy? What have been
the effects of climate, of the struggle with alien peoples and new
environment? How does the food-supply influence {30} the formation of
religious ideas? What contacts have been felt with other races, and
what positive loans or more impalpable influences have passed from one
side to the other? We, find here in _hierology_, the science of "the
Sacred," an analogue to the reasoning which accounts for the
distribution of land and water, the rise of mountain ranges and the
sculpture of valleys and river-beds out of the stratification of the
earth's crust, and builds up a science of geology; or which traces the
results of migration upon peoples, the consequences of inter-marriage
with other tribes, the disastrous issues of war, surveys the immense
variety of causes which have contributed to new developments of racial
energy, and arranges this knowledge in the science of ethnology.
And, lastly, the values of these facts must be estimated. How far can
they be accepted as expressing the reality of the Unseen Power, and
man's relation to it? Hierology may explain how men have developed
certain practices or framed certain beliefs; to determine their
reasonableness is the task of the philosophy of religion or
_hierosophy_.[4]
[4] These three terms have been suggested by Count Goblet d'Alviella,
of Brussels.
The study of "Comparative Religion" assumes that religion is already in
existence. It deals with actual usages, which it places side by side
to see what light they can throw upon each other. It leaves the task
of {31} formulating definitions to philosophy. It is not concerned
with origins, and does not project itself into the prehistoric past
where conjecture takes the place of evidence. An old miracle-play
directed Adam to pass across the stage "going to be created." Whether
religion first appeared in the cultus of the dead, or only entered the
field after the collapse of a reign of magic which had ceased to
satisfy man's demands for help, or was born of dread and desired to
keep its gods at a distance, only remotely affects the process of
discovering and examining the resemblances of its forms, and
interpreting the forces without and within which have produced them.
The sphere of speculation has its own attractions, but in this little
book an attempt will be made to keep to facts.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account