Comparison of Methods of Sewage PurificationPhillips, Theodore Clifford
Science
Comparison of Methods of Sewage Purification
Phillips, Theodore Clifford
Sewage -- Purification
Broad irrigation is a method which cannot generally be used on account
of the large amount of land and labor required. This method is
especially applicable to asylums, alms houses, and reformatories where
cost of labor is small. It is used in the West where the value of all
available water leads to the application of sewage to crops, and also on
account of the low stage of western streams during the summer which
renders sewage discharged into them an unbearable nuisance.
Intermittent downward filtration may be used where there is a
considerable area of sandy soil, and also where a high degree of
purification is necessary.
Chemical precipitation does not require a large area for its operation
and used alone does not give a high degree of purification. Where land
and material for beds is expensive, and partial purification is
sufficient, this system may be used.
The septic tank requires a small area. The odors are not offensive and
cannot be noticed 100 feet away. The effluent may be discharged into
small streams and soon loses its identity.
Contact beds are used where a high degree of purity is required; if the
effluent is emptied into rivers or sources of water supply. The beds do
not require a large area and the process may be recommended if suitable
material is at hand.
The cost of construction and maintenance of the different systems vary
so largely according to local conditions that a fair estimate is not
possible. As the most striking example of maximum and minimum cost the
disposal system at Chicago and at Lowell, Massachusetts may be cited.
The purification in both cases is by dilution, the cost being
practically nothing at Lowell while the Chicago Drainage Canal cost
$33,000,000. It may not be fair to charge this entire cost to the
sewerage system; nevertheless up to date it has been used for no other
purpose.
At Berlin, Germany where broad irrigation is used, the sewage has to be
pumped to the farms and involves a considerable cost. Aside from this
the receipts derived from the sale of farm products are enough to pay
the running expenses of the farm.
The first cost of the intermittent downward filtration plant is
estimated by the writers at $90,000 per million gallons per day of
sewage treated, where the beds are artificial. Where natural beds can be
used the first cost may be reduced to $7,500 per million gallons per
day. The cost of maintenance is about $2.00 per 1,000,000 gallons.
The average cost for operating a chemical disposal plant is about 58
cents per inhabitant per year, or $16.00 per 1,000,000 gallons treated.
At Manchester England where broad irrigation and chemical precipitation
are used in combination, the average cost was $63.00 per 1,000,000
gallons treated.
A septic tank for treating 1,000,000 gallons of sewage per day will cost
less than $10,000 and the cost of maintenance will be about $1.00 per
1,000,000 gallons treated.
_Conclusion_
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account