Corruption in American politics and lifeBrooks, Robert C. (Robert Clarkson)
History
Corruption in American politics and life
Brooks, Robert C. (Robert Clarkson)
Political corruption -- United States; United States -- Social conditions -- 1865-1918
Viewed in this light it must be admitted that our representative
democracy with its great international obligations, its increasing
range of governmental functions, its enormous and unequally distributed
wealth and its intense materialism, is peculiarly subject to corrupt
influence. This does not necessarily mean that the republic is destined
to be overwhelmed by selfishness. It does mean, however, that we
cannot rest secure upon the moral achievements of our ancestors and
the institutions which they have transmitted to us. We must develop a
more robust virtue, capable of resisting the greater pressure that is
brought to bear upon it.
But even if it be conceded that there is a greater measure of
successful temptation among us than in the European nations which twit
us with corruption as our national vice, it does not follow that we
are inferior in political morality to these, our self-appointed moral
censors. Reverting to the illustration of vote-buying, it is evident
that we could stop this particular form of corruption at once by
the simple and obvious, although practically impossible, measure of
abolishing popular suffrage. Assuming, for the sake of the argument,
that this could be accomplished, we might readily find ourselves
burdened with greater political evils than venal voting—for instance,
the development of an arrogant oligarchy and the growth either of
a sodden indifferentism or of a violent revolutionary spirit among
the masses. A large percentage of Prussian citizens of the poorer
classes sullenly refrain from voting, nor are they in the habit of
selling their votes. Presumably some of them would be venal if they
had the opportunity, but the plutocratic three-class election system
makes their political influence so minimal that their ballots are not
worth either the casting or the buying. Neither do Prussian municipal
officials engage in boodling, but the ascription of superior virtue to
them on this account must be tempered by a knowledge of the fact that
the local government of the country is kept closely in leading strings
by the state. Paradoxical as it may seem, it is none the less true
that political corruption implies the existence of political virtue;
it implies trust in the performance of duty, widespread obligation
to perform it, and confidence that in the great majority of cases it
will be performed in spite of the derelictions that such conditions
occasionally entail. If monarchies are less corrupt than democracies,
it is also true that monarchies do not repose so much faith in the
fundamental honesty of their citizens as do democracies. At least they
do not put it to such severe political tests.
* * * * *
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account