While still at Stockholm Mitscherlich showed that the chromates and
manganates are isomorphous with the sulphates, and also that the
perchlorates and permanganates are isomorphous with each other. Although
these facts could not be properly explained at the time, owing to the
inadequate progress of the chemistry of manganese, it was seen that
potassium chromate, K_{2}CrO_{4}, contained the same number of atoms as
potassium sulphate, K_{2}SO_{4}, and that potassium permanganate
KMnO_{4} and perchlorate KClO_{4} likewise resembled each other in
regard to the number of atoms contained in the molecule.
As a good instance of the use of the principle of isomorphism, we may
recall that when Marignac, in 1864, found himself in great difficulty
about the atomic weights of the little known metals tantalum and niobium
which he was investigating, he discovered that their compounds are
isomorphous; the pentoxides of the two metals occur together in
isomorphous mixture in several minerals, and the double fluorides with
potassium fluoride, K_{2}TaF_{7} and K_{2}NbF_{7} are readily obtained
in crystals of the same form. The specific heat of tantalum was then
unknown, so that the law of Dulong and Petit connecting specific heat
with atomic weight could not be applied, and the vapour density of
tantalum chloride, as first determined by Deville and Troost with impure
material, did not indicate an atomic weight for tantalum which would
give it the position among the elements that the chemical reactions of
the metal indicated. Yet Marignac was able definitely to decide, some
time before the final vapour density determinations of Deville and
Troost with pure salts, from the fact of the isomorphism of their
compounds, that the only possible positions for tantalum and niobium
were such as corresponded with the atomic weights 180 and 93
respectively. Time has only confirmed this decision, and we now know
that niobium and tantalum belong to the same family group of elements as
that to which vanadium belongs, and the only difference which modern
research has introduced has been to correct the decimal places of the
atomic weights, that of niobium (now also called columbium, the name
given to it by its discoverer, Hatchett, in 1801) being now accepted as
92.8 and that of tantalum 179.6, when that of hydrogen = 1.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account