Again that monster Ignorance stirs. For as I speak of colour, as I
dogmatise on Titian, I am aware that colour may mean so many different
things, and any one who wished to contradict me would be justified in
doing so, not because I am wrong and he is right, but because of my
difficulty in explaining colour, and his natural wish to aim at my
vulnerable spot. Because I am well-nigh daily breaking bread with
painters who unconsciously reveal the workings of their mind to me, I
know that all the glibly used technical terms of their Art are as fixed
as the colour of a chameleon. Different temperaments take on different
hues. There is colour in Van Eyck and Crivelli, in Bellini and
Botticelli, but deliberate colour harmonies, though arbitrary in choice,
belong to Titian.
Dürer is no colourist, because, as we have already said, painting was
the problem, not the joy of expression--in that he is Mantegna's equal,
and Beato Angelico's inferior.
Thus looking on the "Madonna mit dem Zeisig" at Berlin, we may realise
its beauty with difficulty. For whatever it may have been to his
contemporaries, to us it means little, by the side of the splendid
Madonnas from Italy, or even compared with his own engraved work.
This "Madonna with the Siskin" is a typical Dürer. In midst of the
attempted Italian repose and "beauty" of the principal figures, we have
the vacillating, oscillating profusion of Gothic detail. The fair hair
of the Madonna drawn tightly round the head reappears in a gothic mass
of crimped curls spread over her right shoulder. On her left hangs a
piece of ribbon knotted and twisted. The cushion on which the infant
Saviour sits is slashed, laced, and tassled. The Infant holds a prosaic
"schnuller" or baby-soother in His right hand, whilst the siskin is
perched on the top of His raised forearm. Of the wreath-bearing angels,
one displays an almost bald head, and the background is full of unrest.
Even the little label bearing the artist's name, by which old masters
were wont to mark their pictures, and which in Bellini's case, for
instance, appears plain and flatly fixed, bends up, like the little
films of gelatine, which by their movements are thought to betray the
holder's temperament.
One of the tests of great Art is its appearance of inevitableness: in
that the artist vies with the creator:
"The Moving Finger writes, and having writ,
Moves on; nor all your piety nor wit
Shall lure it back to cancel half a line."
There are a good many "lines" in the "Siskin" Madonna which bear
cancelling: not one in the Madonna of the title-page of the
"Marieenleben," which for that reason is a work of greater Art.
The fact is, that whilst his engraved and black and white work reaches
at times monumental height, great in _saecula saeculorum_, there are too
few of his painted pictures that have the power to arrest the attention
of the student of Art, who must not be confounded with the student of
Art-history.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account