If this is the right interpretation of the passage, we may say at once
that Dante’s astronomical data are imaginary, for the moon was not full
on the night preceding either of these dates, but on March 5, and April
4: Saturn was indeed in Leo, but Venus was so near the Sun as to be
invisible in March, and began to appear as an evening star in Taurus on
about the 9th of April.
These positions were all carefully calculated by Prof. Angelitti, who
is a professional astronomer as well as a Dante scholar; and he made
the thrilling discovery that the positions agree wonderfully well for
the year 1301! In this year the moon was full on the early morning of
the 25th of March; Venus entered Pisces three days later, and was a
morning star, near her greatest elongation west, and very brilliant;
Saturn was not only still in Leo but was just three degrees west of
Regulus; and Mars was also in Leo.
If the anniversary of the Crucifixion means Good Friday, the day would
be March 31 in 1301, and the moon would be wrong, but March 25 has some
claims to be considered the more probable date. A fixed calendar date
is more appropriate to use for calculating an exact number of years
than a changing festival, which might rather be regarded as an “ideal
date.”[533] Moreover, March 25 is suggested by the allusion to the
Creation in the opening Canto; this day was also the traditional date
for the spring equinox,[534] and it was one of the most important days
in the year to Florentines, being their New Year’s Day as well as Lady
Day.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
[533] Moore, _Studies in Dante_ iii. p. 146.
[534] See p. 177.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
We know that the idea of writing his great work was in Dante’s mind
even when he wrote the last words of the _Vita Nuova_,[535] and we need
only suppose that he was thinking of it when he looked at the sky on
the evening before Lady Day in 1301, that he saw the full moon, and
the two bright planets Mars and Saturn making a striking asterism with
Regulus; also that in the early dawn about the same time he rejoiced in
the sight of Venus veiling the Fishes in the east.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
[535] _V. N._ xliii. 1-11.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
But is this attractive theory admissible? Can we take Dante’s words
elsewhere as referring to the year 1301?
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account