It is evident that the moon’s passing in front of the sun implies a
lesser distance from us, and it must have been this which suggested her
place in the scheme of Anaximander. This scheme is rather difficult to
understand, from the allusions and quotations of later writers, for
we have no original writing by Anaximander; but we can gather enough
to show that already in the sixth century B.C. the Greek philosophers
were asking themselves what was the explanation of the movements and
appearances of the heavenly bodies, how they were supported in the
sky, what force moved them, how large and how distant they were, and
what they were made of. Anaximander asserted boldly that sun and moon
were larger than the whole earth: he thought the sun might be 27 and
the moon 19 times as large. How he reached this conclusion it is
impossible to say. The Egyptians had already tried to measure the
apparent size of the sun as compared with the circumference of the sky,
by noting how long it took to set from the moment the lower rim touched
the horizon to the moment when the whole disc disappeared: this,
divided by the 24 hours taken by the sun to traverse the 360 degrees of
the sky, gave the sun’s size in degrees (it is about half a degree),
and had they been able to find the actual distance of the sun from the
earth, they could have deduced its actual size, but this they had no
means of determining.
There are two possible ways of seeing that the moon is smaller than
the sun, although they usually appear to us the same size. Anaximander
may have seen or heard of an “annular” eclipse, in which the moon is
rather more distant from us than at a total eclipse, and therefore
her dark body just fails to cover the whole sun, and a bright ring of
light surrounds her. More probably he realized what was implied in
Thales’ explanation of solar eclipses, and concluded that the moon must
be smaller than the sun, because she looks no larger although she is
nearer to us.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account