About the same time that Anaximander was inventing solid hemispheres and rings to hold and move the heavenly bodies round about a flat earth, Pythagoras was founding a school in southern Italy which gave to the world a very different scheme. One of the characteristics of his school was secrecy, its methods were oral, and his later followers were fond of attributing to their master everything which had gradually grown out of his teaching: it is difficult therefore to say with certainty what he himself taught. It has often been stated by modern writers that he anticipated Copernicus, and discovered that the earth revolves round the sun. Though this is a mistake, we may venture to believe that Pythagoras taught that the earth is a sphere, hanging freely in space. We are so familiar with this idea from childhood, that it is difficult to imagine what a tremendous innovation it was. Pythagorean noviciates, doubtless after solemn initiation and preparation, were told: This earth, which seems to you the floor of the world, with heaven stretched over it like a tent, is a round globe, with men like you living on the other side of it, and yet they do not fall, and earth does not fall, for it is poised in the centre of the world, and has no tendency to fall in one direction rather than in another. Earth, itself a perfect sphere, is in the centre of an infinitely greater sphere, the star-set heaven; and within this seven heavenly bodies move in perfect circles, each at its proper distance and pace, all needing no support and no force to drive them, for harmony is the motive power of the Cosmos. Their distances are proportional to the intervals between musical notes, and as they circle they make heavenly music, which we should hear did we not always hear it, like one who lives beside a waterfall[28]. There is no below, and no above, for above is below and below above to our antipodes: there is but the centre, where we live, and Heaven is all around. ------------------------------------------------------------------------ [28] Some late followers said that Pythagoras, alone amongst men, could hear the music of the spheres. ------------------------------------------------------------------------ How did Pythagoras reach this great and startling truth of the round unsupported earth?