It is, however, only a guess that the Moveable Eccentrics played this part in the theory of Aristarchus. They did not long hold the field, because they were not applicable to Venus and Mercury, which are never seen in opposition to the sun. So they were thrown aside for another system, the Epicycles, which illustrates much more simply the stations and retrogressions of the planets, and can be used for them all. Later on, when more irregularities of motion were discovered, it was found necessary to combine eccentrics and epicycles, and by means of this joint system it became possible at last to represent completely, and as accurately as they could be observed, all the apparent movements of the heavens. First, however, an immense amount of work had to be done, and new methods devised, both in observation and mathematics. The man who contributed most, in both ways, to make it possible, was Hipparchus. 7. HIPPARCHUS. [Sidenote: Hipparchus _c._ 140 B.C.] Of this great man we know scarcely anything but what can be gathered from the work he did, and this corroborates Ptolemy’s description of him: “Hipparchus, lover of toil and truth φιλοπονον και φιλαληθεα.” He lived about B.C. 140, since this is the date of the only book of his still extant, and his work was not done in Alexandria, though he may have studied there in his youth, and he used the Museum records. We count him among the Alexandrians, as he belongs to this era, but he seems to have been a private astronomer, who set up an observatory of his own in Rhodes, his native place. Here we seem to see him, surrounded by his primitive instruments and his papyrus books, patient, eager, modest, seeking no fame and no reward but the joy of his work. By day he would keep watch over the sliding shadow of his gnomon, would write up his observations, make long calculations, and devise new methods in mathematics, improve and modify his astrolabes and his clepsydras; at night he would spend long hours with moon, planets, and stars, making up for the defects and shortcomings of his instruments by the skill and care with which he applied them to measure positions in the sky. Nothing but the most loving and conscientious care could have raised his work to such a pitch of accuracy, and made such rude means suffice for such splendid achievements. The book we possess, apparently an early one, is chiefly concerned with the positions, the risings and the settings, of stars, and at the end is a list of sixteen which came to the meridian at intervals of an hour: from this list and the knowledge of spherical trigonometry which he possessed, it would be possible to calculate the time at night to within about a minute.