Darwin, Charles, 1809-1882; Naturalists -- England -- Biography
But if he liked sincere, earnest argument, he detested controversy,
the bitter war of excited personal feelings bent rather on achieving
an individual triumph than on proving an abstract theory. He
condemned and deplored the injury to science inevitably wrought by
such disputes and had nothing but disgust for the manifestations of
temper that were bound to accompany them: ‘I went the other evening
to the Zoölogical Society, where the speakers were snarling at each
other in a manner anything but like that of gentlemen.’[77]
When his own views were involved in bitterness, as, alas, they too
often were, he expressed the keenest regret: ‘I often think that my
friends ... have good cause to hate me, for having stirred up so much
mud, and led them into so much odious trouble. If I had been a friend
of myself, I should have hated me.’[78] He early made up his mind to
keep out of quarrels if possible, and he congratulated himself on the
whole on his success: ‘I rejoice that I have avoided controversies,
and this I owe to Lyell, who many years ago, in reference to my
geological works, strongly advised me never to get entangled in a
controversy, as it rarely did any good and caused a miserable loss of
time and temper.’[79]
Thus, whenever it was possible, he shunned dispute, and if, by any
chance, haste and eagerness involved him in a mistaken cause, he
bitterly regretted his blunder and was ready to acknowledge it with
the utmost frankness. One of the most striking cases of this is that
of the parallel roads of Glen Roy, as to which Darwin had developed a
geological theory which he asserted with a good deal of conviction.
A careful consideration of his opponent’s arguments, obliged him to
recognize that he was completely in the wrong, and he gave up, though
with a pang: ‘I am very poorly to-day, and very stupid, and hate
everybody and everything. One lives only to make blunders.’[80] His
acknowledgment of his error was ample and complete.
It was his natural frankness in admitting his mistakes and
endeavoring to rectify them which made Darwin so attractive and
engaging. Goethe complains of the disposition of many people to
reiterate a misstatement because they have once made it.[81] Such
reiteration did not appeal to Darwin in the least. Sometimes he was
irritated and annoyed by the attitude of his adversaries, and he
expressed the annoyance with the same outspokenness that he gave to
other things; but there was never any attempt to conceal his blunders
or to maintain his own positions simply because they were his.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account