§ 212. The Antecedent is the condition on which another statement is
made to depend. It precedes the other in the order of thought, but may
either precede or follow it in the order of language. Thus we may say
indifferently--'If the wind drops, we shall have rain' or 'We shall
have rain, if the wind drops.'
§ 213. The Consequent is the statement which is made subject to some
condition.
§ 214. The complex proposition assumes two forms,
(1) If A is B, C is D.
This is known as the Conjunctive or Hypothetical proposition.
(2) Either A is B or C is D.
This is known as the Disjunctive proposition.
§ 215. The disjunctive proposition may also appear in
the form
A is either B or C,
which is equivalent to saying
Either A is B or A is C;
or again in the form
Either A or B is C,
which is equivalent to saying
Either A is C or B is C.
§ 216. As the double nomenclature may cause some confusion, a scheme
is appended.
Proposition
____________|_____________
| |
Simple Complex
(Categorical) (Conditional)
___________|__________
| |
Conjunctive Disjunctive.
(Hypothetical)
§ 217. The first set of names is preferable. 'Categorical' properly
means 'predicable' and 'hypothetical' is a mere synonym for
'conditional.'
§ 218. Let us examine now what is the real nature of the statement
which is made in the complex form of proposition. When, for instance,
we say 'If the sky falls, we shall catch larks,' what is it that we
really mean to assert? Not that the sky will fall, and not that we
shall catch larks, but a certain connection between the two, namely,
that the truth of the antecedent involves the truth of the
consequent. This is why this form of proposition is called
'conjunctive,' because in it the truth of the consequent is conjoined
to the truth of the antecedent.
§ 219. Again, when we say 'Jones is either a knave or a fool,' what is
really meant to be asserted is--'If you do not find Jones to be a
knave, you may be sure that he is a fool.' Here it is the falsity of
the antecedent which involves the truth of the consequent; and the
proposition is known as 'disjunctive,' because the truth of the
consequent is disjoined from the truth of the antecedent.
§ 220. Complex propositions then turn out to be propositions about
propositions, that is, of which the subject and predicate are
themselves propositions. But the nature of a proposition never varies
in thought. Ultimately every proposition must assume the form 'A is,
or is not, B.' 'If the sky falls, we shall catch larks' may be
compressed into 'Sky-falling is lark-catching.'
§ 221. Hence this division turns upon the form of expression, and may
be said to be founded on the simplicity or complexity of the terms
employed in a proposition.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account