DEFENSE OF THE FAITH AND THE SAINTS BY B. H. ROBERTS AUTHOR OF "The Gospel" "Outlines of Ecclesiastical History" "New Witness for God" "Mormon Doctrine of Deity" Etc., Etc. VOLUME II. Salt Lake City 1912 GENERAL FOREWORD No word of Preface is necessary to this Volume, except to say that in presenting it to his readers, the author feels that that he is fulfilling a promise made to them when Volume I of the series was issued. A word of explanation will be found as an introduction to each subdivision of the book, which excludes the necessity of making any reference to such subdivisions in this General Forward. THE AUTHOR. Salt Lake City, January, 1912. TABLE OF CONTENTS GENERAL FOREWORD Part I. ORIGIN OF THE BOOK OF MORMON. Schroeder-Roberts' Debate. Foreword. The Appearing of Moroni. The Book of Mormon. Description of the Nephite Record. THE ORIGIN OF THE BOOK OF MORMON. By Theodore Schroeder. I. Solomon Spaulding and his first manuscript. Spaulding's rewritten manuscript. Erroneous theories examined. II. How about Sidney Rigdon? Rigdon's prior religious dishonesty. Rigdon had opportunity to steal the manuscript. Rigdon's only denial analyzed. Rigdon and Lambdin in 1815. Rigdon exhibits Spaulding's manuscript. Rigdon foreknows the coming and contents of the Book of Mormon. III. From Rigdon to Smith via P. P. Pratt. Rigdon visits Smith before Mormonism. The conversion of Parley P. Pratt. Rigdon's miraculous conversion. The plagiarism clinched. IV. For the love of gold, not God. Concluding comment. THE ORIGIN OF THE BOOK OF MORMON. By Brigham H. Roberts. I. Justifications for replying to Mr. Schroeder. Preliminary considerations. Various classes of witnesses. Conflicting theories of origin. Mr. Schroeder's statement of his case. The facts of the Spaulding manuscript. The task of the present writer. The enemies of the Prophet. "Dr." Philastus Hurlburt. Rev. Adamson Bently, et al. II. The "second" Spaulding manuscript. The failure of Howe's book. The Conneaut witnesses. E. D. Howe discredited as a witness. The Davidson statement. Alleged statement of Mrs. Davidson, formerly the wife of Solomon Spaulding. The Haven-Davidson interview. Mrs. Ellen E. Dickinson's repudiation of the Davidson statement. Reverend John A. Clark and the Davidson statement. Mutilation of the Haven-Davidson interview. Mr. Schroeder and the Davidson statement. Why Mr. Schroeder discredits the Spaulding witnesses. III. The connection of Sidney Rigdon with the Spaulding manuscript. Of Rigdon's alleged "religious dishonesty." Rigdon's opportunity to steal Spaulding's manuscript. Did Rigdon exhibit the Spaulding manuscript. Did Rigdon foreknown the coming and contents of the Book of Mormon? Alexander Campbell and the Book of Mormon in 1831. IV. "The Angel of the Prairies." The supposed meetings of Joseph Smith and Sidney Rigdon before the publication of the Book of Mormon.