Deficiency and Delinquency: An Interpretation of Mental TestingMiner, James Burt
Science
Deficiency and Delinquency: An Interpretation of Mental Testing
Miner, James Burt
Children with mental disabilities; Juvenile delinquents; Mentally ill offenders; Psychological tests
Using our conservative basis for interpreting the results of Binet
examinations, let us now review the evidence of the proportion of
delinquents which is intellectually deficient. We shall compare the
available data on groups of tested delinquents which have not been
subjectively selected, provided that the data permit of restatement on
the basis of the borderlines we have adopted. The evidence of tested
deficiency on over 9000 objectively selected delinquents has thus been
assembled under approximately the same interpretation of the
borderlines. This should help to make it clear how extensive the
preparations must be for dealing with this problem of the defective
delinquent and where the needs are most pressing. It should also enable
us to discover when the estimates have been excessive. We shall confine
ourselves to the reports of objective test examinations, so that the
estimates do not depend upon the judgment of the examiner alone. A
bibliography of these studies is given at the close of the book. How
much more has been accomplished in this field in the United States than
abroad is illustrated by the fact that repeated search has failed to
discover any reports of Binet examinations on representative, randomly
selected groups of delinquents in any foreign country. Binet
examinations have been made of juvenile delinquents in Breslau (_34_)
and in Frankfurt a. M., and in London (_56_); but only upon selected
cases.
Those who wish to compare the results as to tested deficiency with the
subjective opinions of various estimators should consult the reviews of
this literature by Bronner (_6_) and by Gruhle (_121_). The effect of
such a comparison is an increasing conviction that it affords dubious
evidence of the relative amount of deficiency in different groups of
delinquents. Without objective tests, there is no means of telling what
amount of mental retardation the different experts would class as
feeble-mindedness.
(a) WOMEN AND GIRL DELINQUENTS IN STATE INSTITUTIONS.
Women in state penitentiaries are a small group among delinquents in
institutions. According to one study by Louise E. Ordahl and George
Ordahl[15] the frequency of tested deficiency is smaller among them than
among women committed to reformatories, who in general commit less
serious crimes. All except one of the 50 women prisoners enrolled were
tested with the Kuhlmann 1911 revision of the Binet scale. About half
were negro women. Only 6 (4 negroes) tested IX or below and were in our
group of presumably deficient by the tests. Twenty others (13 negroes)
tested one Binet age higher and were in the doubtful group.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account