Deficiency and Delinquency: An Interpretation of Mental TestingMiner, James Burt
Science
Deficiency and Delinquency: An Interpretation of Mental Testing
Miner, James Burt
Children with mental disabilities; Juvenile delinquents; Mentally ill offenders; Psychological tests
were of doubtful ability would be clearly unjustified, and yet this sort
of reasoning about the frequency of deficient delinquents has been all
too common.
Gilliland[24] tested one hundred male inmates of the Columbus, Ohio,
Workhouse (28 negroes) selected so as to attempt to represent the
different offenses about in their proportions. He gives the results in
point scores with the Yerkes-Bridges scale, which may be translated only
roughly into Binet 1911 ages by Haines' data, as I have indicated for
the study by Rossy. All were 18 years of age or over, so that I estimate
14% would fall into our presumably deficient group including only the
proportion of those under 64 points who would test as Binet IX or less.
The doubtful group would include 17% more, including the proportion
under 66 points who would test X or under.
Among the local institutions supported by the county or city, the most
serious delinquency is probably found in the group reported by Kohs at
the Chicago House of Correction (_33_). He tested with the 1911 Binet
scale 335 consecutive cases between 17 and 21 years of age. Among these
were 72 cases (21%) who tested clearly deficient according to our
standard, and 95 cases doubtful, a total of 50% at least uncertain in
intellectual ability.
Through the courtesy of Catherine Mathews, who made the examinations for
the psychological clinic of the University of Pittsburgh, which is under
the direction of Dr. G. C. Bassett, I am able to give the records of 125
consecutive admissions to the Allegheny County Detention Home. The
institution is known as the Thorn Hill School. It is situated some miles
outside of Pittsburgh and provides on the cottage plan for about 300
boys. The boys are sent from the Juvenile Court for milder training than
that at the state school. The school has also been found to furnish a
necessary place to care for cases of feeble-minded delinquent boys who
cannot be immediately admitted to the state institution on account of
its crowded condition. A detention home is also provided in the city for
juvenile court children awaiting trial or the disposition of their
cases. These are not included in the Thorn Hill group.
Among the 125 consecutive cases at Thorn Hill, omitting two cases which
are probably dementia praecox, there were 37, or 29%, who tested
presumably deficient according to our standard, and a total of 68 cases,
or 55%, presumably and doubtfully deficient. It is to be remembered that
our standard for the immature was arranged for the 1908 scale and not
the 1911 scale which was used here, although the difference would be
slight.
TABLE X.
BINET 1911 TESTS OF BOYS CONSECUTIVELY ADMITTED TO THE ALLEGHENY COUNTY
DETENTION HOME AT THORN HILL. (MATHEWS)
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account