Deficiency and Delinquency: An Interpretation of Mental TestingMiner, James Burt
Science
Deficiency and Delinquency: An Interpretation of Mental Testing
Miner, James Burt
Children with mental disabilities; Juvenile delinquents; Mentally ill offenders; Psychological tests
In 1914 Pearson cites estimates of mentally defective children in
several cities by teachers and medical officers based upon the
recommendation of elementary school children for special schools and
classes. These were, for London: boys, 1.59%; girls, 1.09%. For
Liverpool: boys, 0.827%; girls, 0.618%. The corresponding figure for
both sexes in Stockholm is 1.23%. He concludes that “something between
1% and 2% is true for England. Dr. James Kerr, Medical Research Officer,
thinks that the final estimate will be nearer the latter value.”
After giving a table of the percentages at each age in the elementary
schools of Stockholm, Pearson says: “Judged from this table it would
seem that the most reasonable estimate of the prevalence of mental
defect is to be formed when all the mental defectives have been
definitely selected and the normal children have not yet begun to leave
school, _i. e._, at the ages 11 and 12. For Stockholm this leads up to a
mentally defective percentage of about 1.5” (_167_, p. 6-8). In another
place he says that the members of special classes are selected
practically for the same reason, _i. e._, because they are school
inefficients, the bulk of whom will, no doubt, unless provided for
become “social inefficients” (_164_, p. 48). Since some were not
selected because of intellectual deficiency, our social assistance group
should be somewhat smaller.
In 1909-10 the actual number in the schools for mental defectives
maintained by the London County Council was 0.9% of the enrollment of
the London elementary Schools (_143_). The 1912 report of the London
County Council shows 7357 children enrolled in its local schools for
mental defectives, which is 1.1% of the average attendance from
1912-1913 in the elementary county council schools and voluntary schools
of London (_144_, p. 44).
Following a discussion in the Australian Medical Congress of 1911 the
Minister of Public Instruction called for returns as to the number of
feeble-minded in the Australian public elementary schools between 5½ and
14 years of age inclusive. The questionnaire used the definitions of the
British Royal Commission as a description of the various degrees of
retardation and brought returns from 2,241 of the state schools, all
except 57. For their average attendance of 175,000 children, these
teachers classified 1.9% as backward from accidental causes, 2% mentally
dull, 0.42% feeble-minded imbeciles or idiots, and 0.6% epileptics. To
this would be added 0.19% for children in the idiot asylums. The report
states that “the teachers' estimates will thus be realized to be an
absolute minimum, dealing only with the intermediate grades, and not
including the gross cases (idiots, etc.) on the one hand and the less
marked high grades of feeble-minded on the other” (_70_).
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account