Diversions of a NaturalistLankester, E. Ray (Edwin Ray), Sir
History
Diversions of a Naturalist
Lankester, E. Ray (Edwin Ray), Sir
Natural history
In order that natural selection and the survival of the fittest should
have led to this increased size and accompanying educability of the
brain, it is necessary to suppose that the individuals with the
more educable brain as they appeared profited by it, that is to say,
did become more educated, and so defeated their rivals, and survived
and transmitted their increased size of brain little by little in
succeeding generations. There is no difficulty about admitting this
supposition in regard to the passage from higher ape-like creatures
to later forms having a full-sized brain, such as we find in the
Neanderthal man and in some Australians. But we are met here by what
looks, at first sight, as a fact inconsistent with our view. The
obvious increased educability and consequent increased education
of lower races of man by the circumstances of their lives, places
them clearly enough in a position of great advantage over the higher
surviving apes. But when we compare the actual mental accomplishments
of the highest civilized races of man with those of big-brained
savages, we find that a large proportion of individuals in the
civilized races are much farther ahead of the lower savage races than
most of these are ahead of the higher apes. Newton, Shakespeare, and
Darwin are in mental accomplishment farther away from an Australian
black, or even a Congo negro, than these "savages" are from a gorilla
or a chimpanzee. Yet the difference when we compare the size and the
abundance of the convolutions of the brain of the European philosopher
and the black-fellow does not seem, superficially, to be proportionate
to the difference in the mental performance of the two. No minute study
of the microscopic differences in the structure of the two brains
has, as yet, been made, and it is probable that there is a greater
difference here than in the mere shape of the brain-mass. It seems
that the "educability" of the brain measured by its size is little
greater in the one group of men than in the other. And it is found--so
far as observation and experiment have been carried--that individual
savages belonging to races showing very low mental accomplishments in
their native surroundings are yet capable of being "educated" to a far
higher level of mental performance, when removed in early youth from
their natural conditions and subjected to the same conditions as the
better-cared-for children of a civilized race, than any of them ever
reach in their own communities.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account