Diversions of a NaturalistLankester, E. Ray (Edwin Ray), Sir
History
Diversions of a Naturalist
Lankester, E. Ray (Edwin Ray), Sir
Natural history
There is little support in ordinary experience for the belief that
birth-marks are caused by maternal impressions, although some of those
who are concerned in a professional way with breeding operations cling
to it. In very ancient times we find that there was a belief in it,
as shown by the story of the patriarch Jacob, who, wishing to obtain
the birth of spotted or parti-coloured lambs from a herd of sheep,
placed in front of the breeding ewes stakes or rods from which he had
removed the bark in rings, so as to make them parti-coloured. He was
supposed to have been successful in this way in impressing the visual
sense of the maternal ewes with "parti-colouration," and the belief was
that they in consequence produced dappled or parti-coloured lambs. The
belief, though not general, is widespread among simple folk that such
influences can and do act on animals, and it has been, and is by some,
similarly held that a human mother may be influenced by surrounding
objects, so that if her surroundings are beautiful she will produce a
beautiful child. There is absolutely no ground for this belief--based
upon experiment. It is merely an unreasoning assumption of "after this,
therefore because of this," based upon the incomplete observation of a
few accidental cases of vague coincidence and a tenacious clinging to
the belief that it is so because it is difficult to prove that it is
not so. No trustworthy investigation or experiment on the subject is on
record.
But this unwarranted, untested belief, originating among barbarous
peoples, has led further, owing to the inveterate love of marvels
still common among us, to the notion (surviving to the present day)
that the irregular coloured or obscure marks sometimes found on the
skin of a child at birth, and vaguely resembling an animal or a fruit,
or what not, are due to the mother having recently seen, under some
sudden and startling circumstances, the object which the "birth-mark"
on the child resembles. Thus we have the following stories related in
a recent publication ("Sex Antagonism," by Walter Heape, F.R.S.). The
author holds that this strange influence of "maternal impressions"
is possible--a matter of comparatively small importance, since the
real question is not as to the "possibility" but simply (as in a whole
series of beliefs as to more or less improbable occurrences) whether
there is or is not sufficient evidence that the connexion and influence
believed in actually exists. Mr. Heape relates (without giving any
detailed evidence whatever in support of the conclusion which he
accepts) the supposed case of a red "mark" like a lizard found on a
new-born child's breast being "produced" by the fall of a lizard from
the ceiling (the event happened in China) on to its mother's breast
shortly before the child's birth. Another case is that of a woman whose
husband was brought home from work with his arm lacerated by machinery.
Her child was born soon afterwards, and is stated to have had marks on
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account