Diversions of a NaturalistLankester, E. Ray (Edwin Ray), Sir
History
Diversions of a Naturalist
Lankester, E. Ray (Edwin Ray), Sir
Natural history
one arm "similar to" those the mother saw on the corresponding arm of
her husband. Another story is that of a lady who had a great craving
for raspberries before her child was born, and accordingly bore a child
with a red raspberry mark on its body!
In no case does Mr. Heape give any picture of the birth-mark and the
thing supposed to be represented by it, nor state that he has seen
either the mark or a picture of it. In no case is the statement of
the mother as to her having been "influenced" as described in the
narration, tested or examined in any way.
These and similar stories are related to-day, and such stories have
been related from time immemorial. But they are always "hear-say." The
witnesses and the facts are never carefully examined, and the degree
of closeness of the agreement between the mark and its supposed cause
are never really demonstrated. Nor has anyone undertaken a statistical
examination with the view of showing that the vague agreement of the
mark with the arresting object seen by the mother is anything more
than an accidental coincidence, nor (in regard to many such stories)
has it been proved that the mother really did see or notice any such
terrifying object as she afterwards declares (and possibly thinks) she
did. Moreover, no one has carefully and scientifically made crucial
experiments with animals, similar to that of the patriarch Jacob. The
experiments and their record would not be difficult with animals.
Though some farmers may believe that such influences do operate on
their breeding dams, there is no known or recognized application
of Jacob's method to the production of desired form or colour in
domesticated animals. We are not concerned with "possibilities." What
is needed is a series of demonstrative experiments, or critical cases.
And these are, as yet, not forthcoming.
Telegony is the name given to the hypothesis that the offspring of
a known sire sometimes inherit characters from a previous mate of
their dam. The name means reproduction (Greek, gonos) influenced by
a remote agent (Greek, tele = from afar). There is no question about
"possibility" here. Such an "infection" of a dam by a previous mate
is not improbable. According to Darwin "farmers in South Brazil are
convinced that mares which have once borne mules, when subsequently
put to horses, are extremely liable to produce colts striped like a
mule." On the other hand, the Baron de Parana states that he has many
relatives and friends who have large establishments for the rearing of
mules where they obtain from 400 to 1000 mules in a year. In all these
establishments, after two or three crossings of the mare and ass, the
breeders cause the mare to be put to a horse; yet the pure-bred foals
so produced have never in a single case resembled either an ass or a
mule.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account