Doctor and patient : $b Papers on the relationship of the physician to men and institutionsPeabody, Francis Weld
Science
Doctor and patient : $b Papers on the relationship of the physician to men and institutions
Peabody, Francis Weld
Medicine; Medicine -- Practice; Physicians
Here, then, is a great group of patients in which it is not the
disease but the man or the woman who needs to be treated. In general
hospital practice physicians are so busy with the critically sick, and
in clinical teaching they are so concerned with training students in
physical diagnosis and attempting to show them all types of organic
disease, that they do not pay as much attention as they should to the
functional disorders. Many a student enters upon his career having
hardly heard of them except in his course in psychiatry, and without
the faintest conception of how large a part they will play in his
future practice. At best, his method of treatment is apt to be a
cheerful reassurance combined with a placebo. The successful diagnosis
and treatment of these patients, however, depends almost wholly on the
establishment of that intimate personal contact between physician and
patient which forms the basis of private practice. Without this, it is
quite impossible for the physician to get an idea of the problems and
troubles that lie behind so many functional disorders. If students are
to obtain any insight into this field of medicine, they must also be
given opportunities to build up the same type of personal relationship
with their patients.
Is there, then, anything inherent in the conditions of clinical
teaching in a general hospital that makes this impossible? Can you
form a personal relationship in an impersonal institution? Can you
accept the fact that your patient is entirely removed from his natural
environment and then reconstruct the background of environment from
the history, from the family, from a visit to the home or workshop,
and from the information obtained by the social-service worker? And
while you are building up this environmental background, can you enter
into the same personal relationship that you ought to have in private
practice? If you can do all this, and I know from experience that you
can, then the study of medicine in the hospital actually becomes the
practice of medicine, and the treatment of disease immediately takes
its proper place in the larger problem of the care of the patient.
When a patient goes to a physician he usually has confidence that
the physician is the best, or at least the best available, person to
help him in what is, for the time being, his most important trouble.
He relies on him as on a sympathetic adviser and a wise professional
counsellor. When a patient goes to a hospital he has confidence in
the reputation of the institution, but it is hardly necessary to
add that he also hopes to come into contact with some individual who
personifies the institution and will also take a human interest in
him. It is obvious that the first physician to see the patient is in
this strategic position--and in hospitals all students can have the
satisfaction of being regarded as physicians.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account