Does civilization need religion? : $b A study in the social resources and limitations of religion in modern lifeNiebuhr, Reinhold
Religion
Does civilization need religion? : $b A study in the social resources and limitations of religion in modern life
Niebuhr, Reinhold
Christian civilization; Christianity; Philosophy and religion
Catholicism was a compound of early Christianity and the thought and
life of Græco-Roman civilization. The medieval church was a kind of
ghostly aftermath of the Roman empire and the popes were inspired by
the genius of Cæsar as much as by the spirit of Christ. The north
European peoples first accepted this latinized Christianity, partly
because they were attracted by those universal elements in it which
have made their appeal to all peoples, and particularly those of
the Western world, and partly because it was for them the symbol
of the ordered civilization of Rome which they first envied, then
destroyed, and finally tried to rebuild. In time they reacted against
the ecclesiastical, international and feudal solidarities of this
whole politico-religious world, prompted no doubt by the untamed
spirit of liberty which characterized the northern peoples and which
resented the tyranny by which the middle ages achieved their high
measure of social cohesion. Thus Protestantism became the handmaiden
of a budding nationalism which was impatient of the restraints of
an international papacy, as it has since been impatient of every
other type of international control. In time it also came to be the
peculiar spiritual possession of those classes among the northern
peoples who developed modern commerce and industry. The affinity
between its sanctification of the principle of liberty and the
necessary individualism of classes which were intent upon destroying
the traditional restraints of the ancient world for the sake of giving
unhampered play to a growing commercial and industrial life, has been
so perfect that it is hardly possible to decide which of the two is
cause and which effect. Max Weber[6] has made an interesting analysis
of commercial and industrial superiority of Protestant nations. It
may be that the aptitude for commercial and industrial pursuits and
an inclination to the Protestant form of the Christian faith are
concomitant characteristics of north European peoples rather than
casually related phenomena. Yet they have become so intimately related
in history that the most typical commercial classes and nations are
most generally Protestant, and most uniquely Protestant. In England
the nonconformist sects are almost identical with the commercial
middle classes, while the established church with its semi-Catholic
genius has spiritual affinities both with the old Tories and the
new world of the industrial worker. In Germany there is a similar
alignment with Catholic and agrarian Bavaria on the one hand and
the highly industrialized and Protestant Prussia on the other. The
contrast between Protestant and industrial Ulster and Catholic and
agrarian south Ireland is equally significant. Everywhere in Western
civilization, and nowhere more than in America, Protestantism with its
individualism became a kind of spiritual sanctification of the peculiar
interests and prejudices of the races and classes which dominate the
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account