Does civilization need religion? : $b A study in the social resources and limitations of religion in modern lifeNiebuhr, Reinhold
Religion
Does civilization need religion? : $b A study in the social resources and limitations of religion in modern life
Niebuhr, Reinhold
Christian civilization; Christianity; Philosophy and religion
Religion can be healthy and vital only if a certain tension is
maintained between it and the civilization in which it functions. In
time this tension is inevitably resolved into some kind of compromise.
The tendency of religion to become a conservative social force is
partly derived from its ambition to defend the resultant compromise in
the name of its original ideal. Thus all partial values, determined
by geographic, economic, social and political forces, are given a
pseudo-absolute character by the religious elements which entered
into the compromise; and their defects are sufficiently obscured and
sanctified to make them comparatively impregnable to the attacks
of the critics of the status quo. The Russian moujik was more than
ordinarily docile under the tyranny of the czars and more than
ordinarily patient with the imperfections of his society, because his
obedience was claimed not by Russia but by “holy Russia,” the historic
incarnation of his religion. In the same way the medieval church
became organically involved with feudalism and forced the critics of
feudal society to undermine its influence before they could hope to
change the feudal social order. Orthodox Protestantism is intimately
related to this day with Nordicism, with the racial arrogance of north
European peoples. The Ku Klux Klan, which thrives in the hinterlands
of America, maintains its influence over simple minds by screening
racial prejudice against Slavic, Latin and Semitic peoples behind
a devotion to the spiritual treasures of Protestantism and their
defense against the fancied peril of allegedly inferior religions. In
Ireland the racial pride of Ulstermen expresses itself in a passionate
espousal of the Presbyterian religion and a contemptuous attitude
toward the Catholicism of the Irish. In modern prewar Germany there
was a curious partnership between “Thron und Altar,” the interests
of the nationalist German state, as integrated by the Prussian royal
house, with the interests of Protestantism. To this day the fanatic
monarchists of Germany are also Protestant extremists who imagine that
the monarchy was undermined by religiously motivated conspiracies of
Jews and Catholics. Incidentally the Lutheran type of Protestantism
which flourishes in Germany has always been less intimately aligned
with the commercial classes than the Calvinistic sects of other Western
nations. While the German socialists include the Lutheran church among
the forces of reaction with which they must contend, the church’s real
strength is among the peasants and junkers, who are also the strongest
support of monarchist opinion and who abhor the democratic liberalism
of commercial and industrial Germany as much as they despise socialist
radicalism; and they imagine both to be inspired by Semitic designs
upon their national integrity. The real inspiration of this liberalism
with its emphasis on international conciliation and coöperation is
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account