Does civilization need religion? : $b A study in the social resources and limitations of religion in modern lifeNiebuhr, Reinhold
Religion
Does civilization need religion? : $b A study in the social resources and limitations of religion in modern life
Niebuhr, Reinhold
Christian civilization; Christianity; Philosophy and religion
Medieval Catholicism had various strategies in preserving and relaxing
the tension between the ideal of religion and the practical needs of
men and society. It made fewest demands upon the individual. He was
permitted to indulge almost all the natural appetites and ambitions
which characterize the life of the average man. For him the religion of
the church was a magic which guaranteed divine intervention in critical
moments and which offered a rather easy short-cut to the prizes of the
spirit which ought to be won only by virtuous achievement. Yet this
same church had an uncompromising attitude toward the various social
institutions which Protestantism has never equaled. It insisted on the
sacramental nature of the family union with such intransigeance that
it may fairly be accused of failing to make necessary accommodations
of its spiritual ideal to the imperfections of human nature. It dealt
with economic relations with less severity but enforced ethical ideals
upon them which must seem unusually exacting to an age which has become
accustomed to the connivance of Protestantism with laissez-faire
economics. The master of the medieval church, Thomas Aquinas, had
elaborated a theory of the just price for all commercial transactions,
which the church made every effort to apply and which it enforced
through the canonical law. The church did not organize the guilds but
it blessed them; and their efforts to regulate wages, fix fair profits,
insure high quality of merchandise and organize mutual aid among
their members were prompted by a religiously inspired moral idealism.
While it dealt less successfully with the ethical implications of the
relations between landowners and peasants, it impressed the owners
with a sense of their obligation toward those who were economically
dependent upon them which to this day gives the landed aristocracy
of European nations a certain moral superiority over the industrial
overlords who have been trained in more modern schools of thought. The
ambition of the medieval church to dominate the life of the nations
is well known but frequently misinterpreted. The contest between the
papacy and the empire was indeed in some of its aspects no more than
a conflict between two great political organizations lusting for the
power which easily becomes the sole end of the life of social and
political organisms. Yet there was a measure of ethical idealism in
the political aspirations of the popes to which Protestant thought
has given scant justice. In the two greatest exponents of the papacy
as an international political force, Gregory VII and Innocence III,
particularly in Gregory, the ethical ideal of a unified Christian
society which knows how to hold the capricious self-will of nations in
check and how to set bounds to their natural lust for power is of no
small moment in the development of papal policy. The very autocracy of
the papacy, which the modern world finds so little to its liking, was
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account