Does civilization need religion? : $b A study in the social resources and limitations of religion in modern lifeNiebuhr, Reinhold
Religion
Does civilization need religion? : $b A study in the social resources and limitations of religion in modern life
Niebuhr, Reinhold
Christian civilization; Christianity; Philosophy and religion
any superficial intellectualism. If institutions of religion gave
preference to the ethical rather than the intellectual problem of
religious faith, it might be possible to create a religious spirit
sufficiently vigorous to permit the free play of the critical faculties
without a loss of moral or spiritual dynamic. Obviously civilization
cannot afford to dispense with either the irrational moral will or
the critical intelligence by which it is made effective in complex
situations. Men need to subject all partial moral achievements to
comparison with the absolute standards of truth, beauty and goodness of
their religious faith, and yet be able to see and willing to concede
the relativities in the absolute values of their devotion. They can
be saved from a morality of mere utilitarianism only by the religious
quest for an absolute moral standard; yet they need to be discerning
enough to see that every ethical achievement, even when inspired by
religious motives, is tinged with prudential self-interest. They must
continue to strive after freedom and yet realize that human life and
character is largely determined by environment. If they seek happiness,
divorced from fortune, they nevertheless cannot escape the duty of
making the material world serve human welfare. Their ability to
discover the transcendent values in human personality has value only
if they maintain faith in human nature after they have discovered its
imperfections. They must search after the perfect goodness in God and
yet be prepared to face the cruelties of life without either denying
their reality or being driven to despair by them.
If it is true that moral sincerity is even more necessary to a vital
religion in modern life than intellectual modernity, a strategy must
be developed to sever religious idealism from the unethical tendencies
in modern civilization. Any strategy which will succeed in such an
enterprise will savor of asceticism. The limitations of historic
asceticism may teach the present how to avoid inevitable pitfalls
in the task of detaching religious idealism from the corruptions of
society. An asceticism which flees the world and develops its saints at
the price of abandoning industrial civilization even more completely to
the natural and anarchic forces which operate in its life, is obviously
of no use to modern civilization. Yet a type of asceticism is needed,
if for no other reason, because greed is the dominant motive of Western
civilization and nothing less than an ascetic discipline will free
religious idealism from its entanglement with the covetousness of
modern life. Since Western life is intent upon material advantages,
no religious idealism can maintain any degree of purity if it does
not enter into a conscious conflict with the civilization in which it
functions and succeed in setting some bounds to the expansive desires
of men and of nations.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account