Does civilization need religion? : $b A study in the social resources and limitations of religion in modern lifeNiebuhr, Reinhold
Religion
Does civilization need religion? : $b A study in the social resources and limitations of religion in modern life
Niebuhr, Reinhold
Christian civilization; Christianity; Philosophy and religion
The church as such has sufficient spiritual resources to become the
recruiting ground for such a movement of detachment, but it is too
much to hope that it will take the leadership in it. It is too deeply
enmeshed with the interests and prejudices of contemporary civilization
to possess the insight and courage which the enterprise requires. Such
a movement of detachment must be, as it has always been, a minority
movement. But the minority ought not detach itself from the majority
so completely that it will sacrifice the possibility of acting as
a leaven in it. There is no force or strategy which can prevent the
great majority from using religion to give human personality dignity
and self-respect without a serious effort to approximate a moral
ideal which would justify religion’s estimate of human worth. Some
types of religion will continue to obscure the defects in nature and
human nature. They will reassure the perplexed soul by recounting the
victories of the past without seeking new triumphs. They will build
systems of faith upon past experiences without any effort to validate
or amend them in fresh experience. Thus rejuvenation and progress must
come from the few who understand the fuller implications of the faith
which they share with the multitudes whose eyes are holden and who lack
the courage to follow even such visions as may come to them.
A highly spiritual religion cannot be an esoteric possession to which
the multitudes may never aspire. It cannot afford to lose confidence
in the multitudes; yet it must resist the gravitation toward moral
mediocrity among them. It certainly must avoid the cultivation of
a priestly cult into which the layman cannot be initiated. If the
modern movement of detachment is to be effective it must in fact be
a layman’s movement; for it must express itself in rebuilding the
social order rather than in building new religious institutions. Its
most effective ministers will be laymen who will lack neither the
technical skill nor the spiritual resource to deal with the practical
problems of industry and politics. Religious teachers may help to
inspire such a movement, but its efficacy will depend upon those who
are engaged in the world’s work. If the greed of Western civilization
is to be qualified by religious idealism, it will be accomplished by
men who use and direct the machines of modern industry without making
mechanical efficiency an end in itself and without succumbing to the
lure of the material rewards which come so easily to those who are
proficient in the industrial enterprise. A revival of either puritan
or monastic asceticism will be unequal to the task which faces modern
religion. Puritanism sanctified economic power, and monasticism fled
its responsibilities. The new asceticism must produce spiritualized
technicians who will continue to conquer and exploit nature in the
interest of human welfare, but who will regard their task as a social
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account