It is not easy to determine the date of Xenophanes. Timaios said he was
a contemporary of Hieron and Epicharmos, and he certainly seems to have
played a part in the anecdotical romance of Hieron’s court which amused
the Greeks of the fourth century much as that of Croesus and the Seven
Wise Men amused those of the fifth.[267] As Hieron reigned from 478 to
467 B.C., that would make it impossible to date the birth of Xenophanes
much earlier than 570 B.C., even if we suppose him to have lived till
the age of a hundred. On the other hand, both Sextus and Clement say
that Apollodoros gave Ol. XL. (620-616 B.C.) as the date of his birth,
and the former adds that his days were prolonged till the time of
Dareios and Cyrus.[268] Again, Diogenes, whose information on such
matters mostly comes from Apollodoros, says that he flourished in Ol.
LX. (540-537 B.C.), and Diels holds that Apollodoros really said
so.[269] However that may be, it is evident that the date 540 B.C. is
based on the assumption that he went to Elea in the year of its
foundation, and is, therefore, a mere combination.[270]
Footnote 267:
Timaios _ap._ Clem. _Strom._ i. p. 533 (R. P. 95). There is only one
anecdote which actually represents Xenophanes in conversation with
Hieron (Plut. _Reg. apophth._ 175 e), but it is natural to understand
Arist. _Met._ Γ, 5. 1010 a 4 as an allusion to a remark made by
Epicharmos to him. Aristotle has more than one anecdote about
Xenophanes, and it seems most likely that he derived them from the
romance of which Xenophon’s _Strom._ is an echo.
Footnote 268:
Clem., _loc. cit._; Sext. _Strom._ i. 257. The mention of Cyrus is
confirmed by Hipp. _Strom._ i. 94. Diels thinks that Dareios was
mentioned first for metrical reasons; but no one has satisfactorily
explained why Cyrus should be mentioned at all, unless the early date
was intended. On the whole subject, see Jacoby, pp. 204 sqq., who is
certainly wrong in supposing that ἄχρι τῶν Δαρείου καὶ Κύρου χρόνων
can mean “during the times of Dareios and Cyrus.”
Footnote 269:
_Strom._ xxxi. p. 22. He assumes an early corruption of N into M. As
Apollodoros gave the Athenian archon, and not the Olympiad, we might
with more probability suppose a confusion due to two archons having
the same name.
Footnote 270:
As Elea was founded by the Phokaians six years after they left Phokaia
(Herod. i. 164 sqq.) its date is just 540-39 B.C. Cf. the way in which
Apollodoros dated Empedokles by the era of Thourioi (§ 98).
What we do know for certain is that Xenophanes had led a wandering life
from the age of twenty-five, and that he was still alive and making
poetry at the age of ninety-two. He says himself (fr. 8 = 24 Karst.; R.
P. 97):—
There are by this time threescore years and seven that have tossed my
careworn soul[271] up and down the land of Hellas; and there were then
five-and-twenty years from my birth, if I can say aught truly about
these matters.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account