2. There can be no doubt that the founder of the Milesian school, and
therefore the first of the cosmologists, was Thales;[55] but all we can
really be said to know of him comes from Herodotos, and the romance of
the Seven Wise Men was already in existence when he wrote. He tells us,
in the first place, that Thales was of Phoenician descent, a statement
which other writers explained by saying he belonged to the Thelidai, a
noble house descended from Kadmos and Agenor.[56] This is clearly
connected with the view of Herodotos that there were “Kadmeians” from
Boiotia among the original Ionian colonists, and it is certain that
there really were people called Kadmeians in several Ionic cities.[57]
Whether they were of Semitic origin is, of course, another matter.
Herodotos probably mentions the supposed descent of Thales simply
because he was believed to have introduced certain improvements in
navigation from Phoenicia.[58] At any rate, the name Examyes, which his
father bore, lends no support to the view that he was a Semite. It is a
Karian name, and the Karians had been almost completely assimilated by
the Ionians. On the monuments, we find Greek and Karian names
alternating in the same families, and there is therefore no reason to
suppose that Thales was anything else than an ordinary Milesian citizen,
though perhaps with Karian blood in his veins.[59]
Footnote 55:
Simplicius, indeed, quotes from Theophrastos the statement that Thales
had many predecessors (_Dox._ p. 475, 11). This, however, need not
trouble us; for the scholiast on Apollonios Rhodios (ii. 1248) tells
us that Theophrastos made Prometheus the first philosopher, which is
merely an application of Peripatetic literalism to a remark of Plato’s
(_Phileb._ 16 c 6). Cf. Appendix, § 2.
Footnote 56:
Herod. i. 170 (R. P. 9 d.); Diog. i. 22 (R. P. 9).
Footnote 57:
Strabo, xiv. pp. 633, 636; Pausan. vii. 2, 7. Priene was called Kadme,
and the oldest annalist of Miletos bore the name Kadmos. See E. Meyer,
_Gesch. des Alterth._ ii. § 158.
Footnote 58:
Diog. i. 23, Καλλίμαχος δ’ αὐτὸν οἶδεν εὑρετὴν τῆς ἄρκτου τῆς μικρᾶς
λέγων ἐν τοῖς Ἰάμβοις οὕτως—
καὶ τῆς ἁμάξης ἐλέγετο σταθμήσασθαι
τοὺς ἀστερίσκους, ᾗ πλέουσι Φοίνικες.
Footnote 59:
See Diels, “Thales ein Semite?” (_Arch._ ii. 165 sqq.), and Immisch,
“Zu Thales Abkunft” (_ib._ p. 515). The name Examyes occurs also in
Kolophon (Hermesianax, _Leontion_, fr. 2, 38 Bgk.), and may be
compared with other Karian names such as Cheramyes and Panamyes.
[Sidenote: The eclipse foretold by Thales.]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account