5. The introduction of Egyptian geometry into Hellas is universally
ascribed to Thales, and it is extremely probable that he did visit
Egypt; for he had a theory of the inundations of the Nile. In a
well-known passage,[69] Herodotos gives three explanations of the fact
that this alone of all rivers rises in summer and falls in winter; but,
as his custom is in such cases, he does not name their authors. The
first of them, however, that which attributes the floods to the Etesian
winds, is ascribed to Thales in the _Placita_,[70] and also by many
later writers. Now, those statements are derived from a treatise on the
Rise of the Nile attributed to Aristotle and known to the Greek
commentators, but now extant only in a Latin epitome of the thirteenth
century.[71] In this work the first of the three theories mentioned by
Herodotos is ascribed to Thales, the second to Euthymenes of Massalia,
and the third to Anaxagoras. Where did Aristotle, or whoever wrote the
book, get these names? We think naturally once more of Hekataios, whom
Herodotos so often reproduces without mentioning his name; and this
conjecture is much strengthened when we find that Hekataios actually
mentioned Euthymenes.[72] We may conclude, then, that Thales really was
in Egypt; and, perhaps, that Hekataios, in describing the Nile, took
account, as was only natural, of his distinguished fellow-citizen’s
views.
Footnote 69:
Herod. ii. 20.
Footnote 70:
Aet. iv. I. 1 (_Dox._ p. 384).
Footnote 71:
_Dox._ pp. 226-229. The Latin epitome will be found in Rose’s edition
of the Aristotelian fragments.
Footnote 72:
Hekataios, fr. 278 (_F.H.G._ i. p. 19).
[Sidenote: Thales and geometry.]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account