Yet it would be wrong to see in the _Theogony_ a mere revival of the old
superstition. Nothing can ever be revived just as it was; for in every
reaction there is a polemical element which differentiates it completely
from the earlier stage it vainly seeks to reproduce. Hesiod could not
help being affected by the new spirit which trade and adventure had
awakened over the sea, and he became a pioneer in spite of himself. The
rudiments of what grew into Ionic science and history are to be found in
his poems, and he really did more than any one to hasten that decay of
the old ideas which he was seeking to arrest. The _Theogony_ is an
attempt to reduce all the stories about the gods into a single system,
and system is necessarily fatal to so wayward a thing as mythology.
Hesiod, no less than Homer, teaches a panhellenic polytheism; the only
difference is that with him this is more directly based on the legends
attached to the local cults, which he thus sought to invest with a
national significance. The result is that the myth becomes primary and
the cult secondary, a complete inversion of the primitive relation.
Herodotos tells us that it was Homer and Hesiod who made a theogony for
the Hellenes, who gave the gods their names, and distributed among them
their offices and arts,[6] and it is perfectly true. The Olympian
pantheon took the place of the old local gods in men’s minds, and this
was as much the doing of Hesiod as of Homer. The ordinary man had no
ties to this company of gods, but at most to one or two of them; and
even these he would hardly recognise in the humanised figures, detached
from all local associations, which poetry had substituted for the older
objects of worship. The gods of Greece had become a splendid subject for
art; but they came between the Hellenes and their ancestral religions.
They were incapable of satisfying the needs of the people, and that is
the secret of the religious revival which we shall have to consider in
the sequel.
Footnote 6:
Herod. ii. 53.
[Sidenote: Cosmogony.]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account